- Project plans
- Project activities
- Legislation and standards
- Industry context
Last edited 06 Jan 2019
Jane Jacobs and garden villages
In January 2017, the Government announced plans for a new tranche of ‘garden villages’. Spread across 14 sites in England, they will provide 48,000 new homes – communities created at distinct new locations rather than extensions of existing urban areas.
As we consider the merits of these brand new urban developments we should continue to acknowledge the work of Jane Jacobs, the 20th century journalist, activist and urbanist.
Jacobs’ landmark 1961 publication ‘The Death and Life of Great American Cities’ serves as a milestone for how we think, plan, design and experience the places we live in. It presents perspectives and principles of urban development still relevant to modern planners today, including to local authorities and others charged with designing the new garden villages.
“Cities have the capability of providing something for everybody, only because, and only when, they are created by everybody.” (Jacobs, 1961)
‘The Death and Life of Great American Cities’ was an attack on the principles and aims that had shaped modern, orthodox city planning. It was also, and mostly, an attempt to introduce new examples of city planning and rebuilding.
 Building successful and safe communities
A key theory of Jacobs’ 1961 publication was the notion of ‘eyes on the street’.
"…a safe city street doesn’t have to be pretty… it just has to be populated” (Jacobs, 1961)
This advocates the use of high density mixed use communities – areas with residential and commercial uses. This stimulates street traffic, day and night, which not only helps communities flourish socially and economically but also self-polices against criminal and anti-social behaviour.
 Masterplanning and the garden city approach
“His aim was the creation of self-sufficient small towns, really very nice towns if you were docile and had no plans of your own and did not mind spending your life with others with no plans of their own. As in all utopias, the right to have plans of any significance belonged only to the planner in charge.”
What Jacobs meant by this was that we cannot impose communities upon people by creating what we think they should want.
Jacobs later said that as a rule, where cities evolve and change, neighbourhoods built up all at once change little physically over the years and often became stagnant. She believed that such a neighbourhood showed a “strange inability to update itself, enliven itself, repair itself, or to be sought after, out of choice, by a new generation”.
As a child of a British new town (a later incarnation of the garden city movement), this is a striking observation. When we build new infrastructure all at the same time, this means it ages at the same time and the people that we locate in these areas also age at the same pace.
So how should we create new places? An important starting point is to address the transferrable lessons from the past on what has worked well and what hasn’t.
The primary aim of the garden city and new town movements was to integrate communities and employment and to create new places with homes and jobs ready for newcomers to ‘slot into’. But the pace of social, industrial and economic change has left many of these areas unable to adapt to a changing economy and employment opportunities have dwindled as a result of post-industrialisation.
In devising new urban areas such as the proposed garden villages, developers, local authorities and planners would be wise to revisit the Communities and Local Government/ University College London paper on Transferrable lessons from the new towns (2006), which highlighted the successes and failures of this utopian planning.
They would be even wiser to revisit the work of Jane Jacobs, and ‘The Death and Life of Great American Cities’ (1961) which is as relevant today as it was back then.
This article was originally published here by ICE on 9 Jan 2017. It was written by Adam Kirkup.
 Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
- Articles by ICE on Designing Buildings Wiki.
- Garden town.
- Garden village.
- Howell Killick Partridge and Amis.
- Landscape urbanism.
- Public space.
- The landscapes of Cambridge.
- The Past and Future City.
- Town and Country Planning Association.
- Towns and cities in history.
- Urban design.
- Vital Little Plans - book launch.
Featured articles and news
Well-designed lighting helps maintain a healthy physiological and psychological balance.
Transferring the risk for obtaining the target BREEAM rating.
A simple but effective way to determine the root cause of an issue.
BSRIA report suggest the European market will double to 415 million Euros by 2023.
Do you understand the different types of stone and which ones you should use where?
Why a wellbeing strategy is vital for property managers.
An ECA briefing for members about the commercial implications of leaving the EU.
A crucial moment on any project - and fraught with danger.
The performance gap from a Northern Ireland perspective.
Book review: Buildings of protestant nonconformity.
Design and testing for health and wellbeing - free download from BRE.