The Construction Historian, Issue 9, March 2022
In The Construction Historian (Issue 9, March 2022) Michael Heaton offers a short article entitled ‘Another Fine Mess…’, looking at mistakes (or mistaken understanding) in construction. Heaton observes that engineering history, especially that of vernacular structural carpentry, assumes that craftsmen builders had an innate understanding of the capacity of materials and structures to withstand and transfer the forces created by and operating on the structures they built. As we rarely find, or report, evidence of failures, we assume that structural forms were developed and improved in response to the changing demands of society in careful empirical stages.
In the case of roof trusses for duo-pitched roofs, the many forms developed in Europe during the last c2,000 years all perform the same two functions in slightly different ways: restraining the outward thrust of the pitches under load while, if possible, creating a usable space within the roof (the interrupted tie-beam roof truss is a good example of this). A common truss form in small 19th-century British stables is needed for a usable space in the low-pitched roof for storing feed or staff accommodation. A rigid structural triangle has to resist outward thrust of the loaded principal rafters without needing the full span of the tie-beam that would ordinarily render the roof space difficult to use.
In the case Heaton observed, the carpentry had allowed the roof to spread outwards, threatening the imminent collapse of the building. This demonstrates that, contrary to received engineering history, the designer (or carpenter) of this early-19th-century roof truss did not understand statics. Although assumed to be experienced and competent, they were copying a structural detail they had seen elsewhere, possibly in a book, (that is, fashion) without understanding how it worked, which suggests also not knowing how the traditional forms actually worked.
Also of note is an article by Edwin AR Trout about the Orchestrelle Factory, Benlow Works, in Hayes, Middlesex, a Grade II listed building at risk. The name was closely associated with the fashion of the day for mechanised music (the pianola), and was both the name of a musical instrument and its manufacturer. The four-storey building was designed in 1909 for the Aeolian Organ and Music Company by Walter Cave, with distinctive full-height Diocletian windows. It was constructed in a material new at the time, Stuart’s Granolithic Stone, a form of reinforced concrete. A possible reuse is being explored, but the future of this significant building, described at the time of its construction as ‘one of the most important undertakings in reinforced concrete construction erected in this country… A noteworthy example of the practical use of reinforced concrete for factory construction’ is not yet secured.
This article originally appeared as: ‘The Construction Historian’ in the Institute of Historic Building Conservation’s (IHBC’s) Context 172, published in June 2022. It was written by Bob Kindred MBE.
--Institute of Historic Building Conservation
Related articles on Designing Buildings
IHBC NewsBlog
IHBC Membership Journal Context - Latest Issue on 'Hadrian's Wall' Published
The issue includes takes on the wall 'end-to-end' including 'the man who saved it'.
Heritage Building Retrofit Toolkit developed by City of London and Purcell
The toolkit is designed to provide clear and actionable guidance for owners, occupiers and caretakers of historic and listed buildings.
70 countries sign Declaration de Chaillot at Buildings & Climate Global Forum
The declaration is a foundational document enabling progress towards a ‘rapid, fair, and effective transition of the buildings sector’
Bookings open for IHBC Annual School 12-15 June 2024
Theme: Place and Building Care - Finance, Policy and People in Conservation Practice
Rare Sliding Canal Bridge in the UK gets a Major Update
A moveable rail bridge over the Stainforth and Keadby Canal in the Midlands in England has been completely overhauled.
'Restoration and Renewal: Developing the strategic case' Published
The House of Commons Library has published the research briefing, outlining the different options for the Palace of Westminster.
Brum’s Broad Street skyscraper plans approved with unusual rule for residents
A report by a council officer says that the development would provide for a mix of accommodation in a ‘high quality, secure environment...
English Housing Survey 2022 to 2023
Initial findings from the English Housing Survey 2022 to 2023 have been published.
Audit Wales research report: Sustainable development?
A new report from Audit Wales examines how Welsh Councils are supporting repurposing and regeneration of vacant properties and brownfield sites.
New Guidance Launched on ‘Understanding Special Historic Interest in Listing’
Historic England (HE) has published this guidance to help people better understand special historic interest, one of the two main criteria used to decide whether a building can be listed or not.