The Pattern of Traditional Roofing
The Pattern of Traditional Roofing, Gerald Emerton, privately printed, 2018, 352 pages, 379 colour and black and white illustrations and line drawings, softback, from Glebe House, Acton, Nantwich CW5 8LE
Gerald Emerton is a fourth-generation slater and tiler based in the north west of England, whose sons and grandsons continue the business today. The author of ‘The Pattern of Scottish Roofing’, published by Historic Scotland, he has brought his wealth of experience and knowledge to the subject of vernacular roofing across England and Wales. The book is structured around the materials used and their regional particularities, with historical accounts gained from documentary sources, company records and historic manuals.
The first section describes the various gritstone and sandstone slates which are found almost exclusively in the localities where they were quarried, including the Pennines, West Yorkshire, East Cheshire, the Lancashire Moors, the Cumbrian Fells and the Welsh Marches. A section follows on the limestone beds suitable for roofing. These are found mostly in a belt stretching from Sherbourne at the southern end to Cirencester to the north. The roofs made of small, thick stone slates found in Cotswold villages are among the most beautiful in Britain, but require exceptional skill to lay.
The chapter on natural slates covers Westmorland green slates, the Welsh quarries and a small outcrop in the Charnwood Forest area known as Swithland slates. Plentiful slate quarries were widely spread across Wales and served their local communities, but the huge quarries of Bangor, Caernarvon and Blaenau Ffestiniog led to the opposite result in the 19th century, being delivered by rail and sea to all parts of the country. Emerton focuses on the small quarries, almost all of which have now been closed down, regretting the fact that the big industrial quarries are incapable of producing consignments of random slates and thus have limited relevance for heritage slating work.
While the author claims it was not his intention to produce a training manual, each chapter contains passages on roofing techniques. One describes the creation of slated valleys, which have always been a complex issue for both carpenter and slater, and of which there are many different methods (all naturally without the use of cement mortar). Another covers the means by which quarrymen calculate the quantity of slates required to cover a random slate roof, and the subsequent sorting and setting out of the material by the slater to ensure a successful result.
The final section deals with clay roof tiles. As with slates, these can be distinguished by their geological characteristics. The different clays used determine their colour and texture, and their sizes and forms differed across the country. The author’s photographs are a major feature of the book. They show the diversity of roofing slates and tiles, the methods of setting out, the design traditions and the detailed treatment of eaves, valleys and hips across the country. Looking at these, it is clear how present-day barn conversions and re-roofing of vernacular buildings with machine-made tiles, each an exact image of its neighbour, bland in colour, with sawn-cut verges and half-round ridges have harmed the rural scene. These, he ironically observes, display the desire of many of our decisionmakers, including those conscious of our built heritage, to ‘admire a neatly-laid, hand-made pantile roof with detailed finishes which do not offend the appearance of the limitations of the past’.
In comparison with brick and stone, the art of roofing has received limited attention, and this makes Emerton’s book an invaluable tool for all conservation professionals. It is also a salutary reminder of the distinctive traditions that continue to be eroded by the loss of craftsmanship and understanding.
This article originally appeared as ‘Laddertop view’ in Context 165, published by The Institute of Historic Building Conservation in August 2020. It was written by Peter de Figueiredo, reviews editor of Context.
Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
The support will create dozens of opportunities in heritage repair and construction and waterways management, funded by the Department for Work and Pensions.
The 2021 edition of the Building Conservation Directory, also available online, has been published. Find skilled trades specialising in work to historic and traditional buildings.
BT has revealed that almost 4,000 of its iconic red phone boxes across the UK are available for local communities to adopt for just £1.
On 26 March the IHBC, led by Prof. John Edwards, hosted a free one-hour CPD webinar ‘Introduction to Building Survey for Retrofit’ for sector professionals.
Greg Clark, writing an opinion piece for RICS, explores how good governance in cities pays dividends.
The Architectural Heritage Fund has issued a report on the first year of its ‘Transforming Places Through Heritage’ grants programme, funded by DCMS.
Europe’s star cities are scattered all over Europe but their perfect geometrical beauty can only be fully admired when seen from above.
The freely available Insight 1 series targets a wide range of cohorts who wish to gain an appreciation of practical heritage conservation.
The restoration and renewal of the Palace of Westminster is of ‘paramount importance’ according to the recent strategic review.
The IHBC's monthly CPD Circular showcases upcoming Events, Awards, Placements, Bursaries & Scholarships, Calls for Papers and more from across the UK and beyond.