Stakeholder management for building design and construction

Contents 1 Stakeholders 2 Stakeholder classification 2.1 Direct stakeholders 2.2 Indirect stakeholders 2.3 Positive stakeholders 2.4 Negative stakeholders 2.5 Legitimacy and power 3 Stakeholder management 3.1 Stakeholder management strategies 3.1.1 1. Inform 3.1.2 2. Consult 3.1.3 3. Involve 3.1.4 4. Partner/collaborate 4 Find out more 4.1 Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki 4.2 External references

[edit] Stakeholders

A stakeholder is anyone who has an interest in the process or outcome of a project (Fewings, 2005.) In a typical construction project any or all of the following may be a stakeholder; the client, the principal contractor, designers, subcontractors, people employed in any capacity in the project, local authorities, the end users of the product, professional bodies, local residents, local business owners, politicians, environmental groups, and many more.

[edit] Stakeholder classification

[edit] Direct stakeholders

Direct stakeholders are those directly associated or involved in the project. These include the client, project sponsor, project manager, members of the project team, technical and financial services providers, internal or external consultants, material and equipment suppliers, site personnel, contractors and subcontractors as well as end users (Lester, 2007). They are also known as internal stakeholders.

[edit] Indirect stakeholders

Indirect stakeholders are those indirectly associated with the project, such as; internal managers of the organisation and support staff not directly involved in the project, national and local government, public utilities, licensing and inspecting organisations, technical institutions, professional bodies, and personal interest groups such as stockholders, labour unions and pressure groups (Lester, 2007). They are also known as external stakeholders.

[edit] Positive stakeholders

Positive stakeholders are those who are likely to have a favourable impact on a project. These people or organisations tend to also be direct stakeholders, and stand to gain from the project’s success. Examples would be the organisations involved in the work itself that stand to benefit financially.

[edit] Negative stakeholders

Negative stakeholders are those who are likely to have a detrimental impact on a project. They tend to be people or organisations not directly involved in a project, but who are still affected by it in some way. An example would be local residents with concerns about loss of public areas to a new project. (Burke, p40)

[edit] Legitimacy and power

Stakeholders are further differentiated between those with legitimacy and power, and those without it, as this will influence the degree to which they can affect the project, whether positively or negatively.

• Legitimacy is the perceived validity of a stakeholder’s claim to importance on the project.
• Power is the stakeholders ability to influence the project and the parties involved in some way, whether finically, legally or by some other form of pressure (Olomolaiye & Chiniyo, 2010).

[edit] Stakeholder management

In order to run a successful project it is important to address the needs of the projects stakeholders, effectively predicting how the project will affect them and how they can affect the project. The effective management of project stakeholders is considered an important key to project success (Olomolaiye & Chiniyo, 2010). Ineffective stakeholder management can result in dissatisfaction with the final product and negative impacts on the projects budget and schedule (Olomolaiye & Chiniyo, 2010).

[edit] Stakeholder management strategies

During the development stages of a project, a stakeholder management strategy should be developed. An organisation should consider the following factors when developing a stakeholder management plan (Caroll and Buchholtz, 2006):

• Who are our stakeholders?
• What are their stakes?
• What opportunities do they present?
• What challenges or threats do they present?
• What responsibilities do we have towards our stakeholders?
• What strategies or actions should we use to engage our stakeholders?

This process will allow the projects stakeholders to be effectively mapped out. The next step is to assess their key characteristics and present this information in a way that helps the project team implement effective stakeholder management initiatives (Olomolaiye & Chiniyo, 2010,). While it may not be possible to please all stakeholders on every project, effective stakeholder management should endeavour to satisfy as many as possible, which will often involve strategic prioritisation of the different stakeholders needs. A common technique used for this is the stakeholder matrix or stakeholder map, which allows the priority level of the stakeholder to be assessed using the power and legitimacy criteria previously described.

The result of these processes is a 4-tier hierarchy of stakeholder importance levels, which will dictate how stakeholders are managed during the course of a project:

[edit] 1. Inform

This category contains those stakeholders who require minimal effort. Stakeholders with lower power but higher legitimacy need to be kept informed of decisions taken that may affect them directly (Olomolaiye & Chiniyo, 2010).

[edit] 2. Consult

These are stakeholders who require more than just being informed about the project. Since the secondary stakeholders with higher power but lower legitimacy need to be kept onboard they should be consulted in order to seek their opinions and input for key decisions that directly or indirectly affect them. It is unlikely that the strategy will be altered as a result of such consultation, but tactics may be adjusted to maintain higher levels of commitment (Olomolaiye & Chiniyo, 2010).

[edit] 3. Involve

Stakeholders with high power levels, even those with low legitimacy, need to be involved in all activities in the project according to their interest since they have power to make decisions that impact on the project. The management should work directly with these stakeholders to ensure that their concerns are consistently understood, considered, and reflected in the projects development (Olomolaiye & Chiniyo, 2010).

[edit] 4. Partner/collaborate

Primary stakeholders have high enough levels of legitimacy and power to effect project success and as such, they should be treated as partners to increase their engagement and commitment. This can be achieved by revising and tailoring project strategies, objectives, and outcomes if necessary to win their support (Olomolaiye & Chiniyo, 2010).

[edit] Find out more

[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki

• Champions.
• Collaborative practices
• Consultation process.
• Design quality.
• Design review.
• Egan report.
• Latham Report.
• Stakeholders.
• Stakeholder map.
• Third party dependencies.
• User panels.
  

[edit] External references

• Carroll, A & Bucholtz, A. (2012) Buisness & Society: Ethics, Sustainability and Stakeholder Management. 8^th ed. Mason, OH. South-Western Cengage Learning
• CSCS Website (2013). [online]. [Accessed April 20^th 2013]. Available at: http://www.cscs.uk.com/CCSheme Website (2013). [online]. [Accessed April 20^th 2013]. Available at: http://www.ccscheme.org.uk/index.php/ccs-ltd
• Fewings, P. (2005) Construction project management: an integrated approach. Abingdon: Taylor Francis
• Lester, A. (2007) Project management, planning and control. 5^th ed. Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann
• Olomolaiye, P & Chiniyo, E. (2010) Construction stakeholder management. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell

Comments

I like the stakeholder categories which covers all key categories. It may also be worth considering stakeholders not just by category, but also by power and interest. To this use a square split it into four smaller squares, label the bottom of the square interest and the left side of the square power. Analyse your stakeholders using these two parameters so that you identify key players - high interest & high power, least important - low interest & low power and so on. This page http://www.stakeholdermap.com/stakeholder-analysis.html gives a step by step tutorial to analyse stakeholders.