- Project plans
- Project activities
- Legislation and standards
- Industry context
Last edited 30 Jan 2019
Soft landings and design for performance
Design for Performance (DfP) aims to change the way we design new commercial office developments in the UK and end the culture of satisfying theoretical energy efficiency metrics. DfP instead targets performance outcomes, using a process which commits a signatory from the outset to achieving a specific base building an energy rating, verified by measurement.
Unlike the energy used by tenants for their lighting and IT, a base building energy rating can be secured by a developer with support from supply side stakeholders. Because it represents the operational energy efficiency of the property asset, the base building rating is a metric of interest to investors targeting lower carbon portfolios and, notably, to potential tenants, because it can be associated with building quality, reflecting the reality that a better rating will be the result where a building is better designed, better constructed, better commissioned and better maintained and operated. At present, the UK commercial office market targets compliance with Building Regulations and EPC ratings: energy efficiency endeavours currently focus on design and technology that improve predicted performance. DfP requires a relentless focus on performance outcomes, with specific activities required at each Soft Landings Phase, as follows.
The essential starting point is for the building developer to set a base building energy target and commit to design, construct and commission the premises to operate at the target level. Written notice of the target must be provided to all consultants and contractors involved. All parties must commit to allowing the operational performance to be measured and disclosed after 12 months of full occupation.
The building services consultant must undertake simulation of the building including its HVAC system and controls to predict actual base building energy use and establish measurable monthly subsystem targets. The design and simulation must be subjected to an independent review by an approved expert as part of the Soft Landings reality-checking process. Changes arising from the review should be consolidated into the final design package.
 Phase 3: Construction
During the construction phase, it is important to keep the simulation model and Description of Operations up to date with any significant design changes and ensure achievement of the target is not compromised by value engineering. The draft Description of Operations should be made available to tenderers for the controls engineering.
A key objective should be for the implemented controls to be consistent with the simulation model of the final design and the revised Description of Operations. The building services consultant should have effective oversight of tenant fit-outs, including veto of proposals which would stop the target rating being achieved.
 Phase 5: Initial aftercare
Extended commissioning, monitoring and intensive post-occupancy fine-tuning should include tracking the rating using a mix of actual and forecast energy use for the first 12 months of operation. These activities must be built into the remit of the building services consultant, control engineers, managing agents and facilities managers, and reinforced by performance-based maintenance contracts, linked to achievement of the target rating.
 Phase 6: Extended aftercare and POE
The contractor should retain enough control during the first year of occupation to ensure the FM team can deliver the target performance in year 1. The FM team can then be expected to continue to achieve it in subsequent years. Contractual retentions might be placed on the builder and mechanical contractor based on energy-rating performance i.e. performance failure could be treated as a defect.
The end-of-period independent formal assessment of the base building rating would then have to be completed prior to contractual release. Typically, the landlord should provide tenants with annual updates of the base building rating for the duration of their leases.
This article was written by Robert Cohen, Technical Director, Verco, and published by BSRIA in January 2019 at https://www.bsria.co.uk/news/article/soft-landings-and-design-for-performance/
Featured articles and news
The admissibility of evidence.
How many can you name? 37 anyone?
CIOB respond to the points-based system.
When is the weather considered 'exceptionally adverse'?
ECA backs call for a rolling programme of rail electrification.
What does 'curtilage' mean and why does it matter?
Our duty to prevent harm and protect each other.
A quality perspective.
If buildings were people, they would be just starting to walk on two legs.
Air filtration and clean air standards.
The Dukes of Normandy and the second world war.