Project benchmarking
See also: Benchmarking as business tool.
Benchmarking is a process by which the estimated performance (often cost) of a project is compared to other similar projects. This can highlight areas of design that are not offering good value for money and can help in the assessment of tenders from suppliers and contractors.
Benchmarking is increasingly being carried out on public projects, where the government has access to large amounts of cost data for similar projects. For example, when analysis of the recent schools programme was carried out, it was found that it '... exposed variations in costs that could not be justified by project differences' (ref. Cabinet Office: Government Construction Strategy, May 2011).
It is now proposed that cost benchmarking should be carried out across all government capital programmes to create baselines for a cost/value-led approach to procurement.
In the private sector, comparable cost information may not be so readily available. However, large organisations may have access to in-house cost information, and some cost information is published. Comparative information can also be purchased from sources such as the Building Cost Information Service (BCIS). See BCIS Online for a description of the tender price and duration information available.
It is important, however, that benchmarking does not simply consider construction costs, as these are only a small proportion of whole-life costs, and setting a low benchmark for construction could result in higher operating, maintenance and refurbishment costs throughout the life of the building.
There is now an increasing amount of data available about energy use, sustainability and whole-life costs such as:
- CarbonBuzz, an on-line service that allows architects and engineers to share project forecasts and energy use anonymously.
- The Carbon Trust Energy Benchmarking
- The Chartered Institute of Building Services Engineers.
- Building Research Establishment Environmental Assessment Method (BREEAM).
- Closing the Loop – Benchmarks for Sustainable Buildings (RIBA).
It is important also to consider both quality and time, as the lowest cost option may not always offer the best value for the client or deliver a completed project within the required timeframe.
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
- Acceleration of construction works.
- Additionality.
- Benchmark.
- Benchmarking as business tool.
- Best practice.
- Business case.
- Carbon Buzz.
- Cash flow statement.
- Construction project.
- Demonstration project.
- Design-Build Institute of America DBIA.
- Design review.
- Design quality.
- Earned value analysis.
- Estimate.
- Health performance indicators in the built environment.
- Identifying the causes of trends in construction labour productivity.
- Independent review of construction frameworks.
- Key performance indicators.
- Pareto analysis.
- Practice.
- Productivity in construction: Creating a framework for the industry to thrive.
- Project performance management.
- Public sector comparator.
- Time management of construction projects.
- Value management techniques.
- Whole-life costs.
[edit] External references
- Government construction strategy, Page 11.
Featured articles and news
IHBC’s response to Parliamentary Committee
On Levelling-Up and Regeneration Bill.
Finalists for 2022 CIOB Awards revealed
Over 70 managers and organisations shortlisted for the 14 awards.
Types of building sensors on BD
From biometric to electrical current, chemical and more.
Government mandates detectors in rented homes
Changes are due to come into force on 1st October 2022.
80% of major government projects are rated red or amber
Heed advice and insight of this report IPA tells the government.
The end of the games but continued calls for action
From the Commonwealth Association of Architects.
CIOB respond to the government call for evidence
For the Levelling Up, Housing & Communities Committee.
How are buildings and their occupants responding to extreme heat?
BSRIA's Technical Director reflects on recent weather patterns.
Landownership in England in 1909
A national valuation to fund old-age pensions.
The world’s largest Commonwealth memorial to the missing.
Long after the end of the defects liability period.
BSRIA Occupant Wellbeing survey BOW
Occupant satisfaction and wellbeing in buildings.
Geometric form and buildings in brief
From the simple to the complex.
Understanding the changing nature of insulation
And the UK Government guidelines.
Three year action plan to improve equity, diversity and inclusion
Commitment agreed to by major built environment bodies.
The Construction Route – what needs to change?
Electrical skills, low carbon, high-tech and the building services revolution.
Deep geothermal power possibilities
Ultra-deep drilling with millimeter-wave beam technology.
BSRIA Briefing 2022- From the outside looking in
Looking at the built environment from space.
Competence requirements for principal contractors and designers
BSI standards 8671, 8672 and 8673.
Bringing life to burial grounds.
From failed modernism to twenty-minute neighbourhoods.
Design chill and design freeze
The gates process and change control.
Comments
To start a discussion about this article, click 'Add a comment' above and add your thoughts to this discussion page.