- Project plans
- Project activities
- Legislation and standards
- Industry context
Last edited 13 Feb 2018
PFIs and adjudication
PFI projects are necessarily complex in their contractual structure and the number of parties involved tends to be greater than in traditional procurement. That in turn can lead to a greater number of disputes than before and of greater complexity.
The growth in PFI activity in the 1990s and 2000s was in parallel to the developments in statutory provisions for adjudication through the HGCRA. PFI agreements are excluded from the provisions of the act through accompanying legislation, but that exclusion does not apply entirely to PFI subcontracts which are construction contracts under the act.
S.113 of the act prohibits pay-when-paid clauses which leads to an inability to fully enforce equivalent project relief provisions (ways of enforcing back-to-back risk transfer down the supply chain) by PFI project companies.
This was the situation in Midland Expressway. Project companies are typically thinly capitalised and prolonged disputes involving subcontractors and potentially the public sector authority can cause significant cash flow difficulties. Subsequent contracts legislation in 2011 eased this burden slightly but the ban on pay-when-paid remains.
These characteristics point to the usefulness of adjudication as a relatively quick form of dispute resolution in the PFI market. The joining of related disputes is a helpful feature as most disputes involve more than two parties and more than one contract.
Despite the S.113 exemption, PFI project agreements almost always contain contractual adjudication provisions for dispute resolution which tend to be closely followed by those drafting subcontracts, for example using the same panel(s) of adjudicators.
Better value from existing private finance initiatives:
The UK government's austerity measures brought in after the credit crunch led public authorities to seek better value from existing PFI agreements and this in turn has led to a significant rise in disputes under PFI contracts between authorities, project companies and subcontractors.
Most public bodies, and probably their contractual partners, prefer to avoid the sometimes unflattering exposure brought by litigation so once again adjudication is a natural route to take given its confidentiality.
Disputes between private sector parties about the responsibilities for asset maintenance and asset replacement are now common and are now being seen frequently in adjudications. Also common at present are disputes brought by public authorities for building defects.
The long-term nature of PFI agreements (typically at least 25 years), means that the market isn't going to disappear despite the slowness of government to develop replacement models for PFI-style projects. Whether the current propensity to disputes will continue, only time will tell.
This article was originally published here on 8 March 2017 by ICE. It was written by Patrick Waterhouse - a construction adjudicator and is on ICE's panel of adjudicators and panel of conciliators/mediators.
 Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
- Articles by ICE on Designing Buildings Wiki.
- Adjudicators and bias.
- Causes of construction disputes.
- Concession agreement.
- Equivalent project relief provisions.
- Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act HGRA.
- Midland Expressway Ltd v Carillion Construction Ltd & Others.
- Private finance initiative.
Featured articles and news
If events occur that cause the completion of the works to be delayed then these may be compensation events.
BSRIA's new Building MOTs Scheme is designed to provide guidance on the next steps after compliance.
At an ICE discussion, the focus was on delivering a Northern Infrastructure Strategy based on opportunity for all.
The Considerate Constructors Scheme officially launch the new Ultra Site status for contractors and supply chains.
The risk of specification errors in the cladding sector is "worryingly high" after Grenfell, according to major distributor.
Here is our outline work plan for a private sector design and build project.
BRE are to publish new guidance aimed at assuring buyers as to the merits of off-site construction methods.
Who are the various different stakeholders in development projects? Find out in our introductory article.
How a BRE office became the centre-piece for major biophilic design research.
A new interactive virtual experience allows visitors to explore ICE 200 exhibition from anywhere.