Evaluation of claims
Contents |
[edit] Introduction
Claims commonly arise between the parties to construction contracts. This can be as a result of delays, changes, unforeseen circumstances, insufficient information and conflict. Claims might be made for things such as loss and expense, extension of time and liquidated damages. The contract should set out exactly what can constitute a claim and how it should be dealt with. There may also be claims associated with the appointment of consultants.
Evaluation is the process of assessing disputed issues associated with a claim. The article, Evaluation and Preparation of Claims in Construction Projects, suggests the evaluation process most commonly relates to lost money or extensions of time - or “...costs associated with prolongation and costs associated with disruption. As Burden of Proof is on the claimant, the claimant must show that there is a direct link (causal link) between the breach (cause) and the loss (effect) thereby sustained.”
[edit] Examining the evaluation process
According to the book, Evaluating Contract Claims by John Mullen, Peter Davison, the claim evaluation process can include an examination of duty, cause, effect and damage. The book states, “The prime source of information for any evaluation has to be the contract between the parties and its requirements. There is no substitute for reading the contract and any incorporated relevant documents. Regrettably, this is often a starting point more often honoured in the breach than in observance in practice.”
Claims must be properly constituted and documented. This means:
- Proper legal entitlement must be established.
- Cause and effect must be clearly demonstrated by contemporaneous records.
- Additional costs must be backed up by full supporting documents.
Records from both parties may be considered in the evaluation of claims. Records may include:
- Tender and contract documentation.
- Staffing/labour records.
- Materials/equipment records.
- Correspondence.
- Photographs/videos.
Any other documents exchanged between the parties related to scheduling, pricing, risk or eventual project outcome may also be used in the evaluation of claim. These records should be accurate and include substantial details, “...to the standard required in formal dispute resolution procedures under English law,” according to Mullen and Davison.
Certain types of contract may be more susceptible to claim issues than others.
The fixed price contract, which is defined by The Code of Estimating Practice, seventh edition, published by the Chartered Institute of Building (CIOB) as, ‘…a contract where the price is agreed and fixed before construction starts’. Under a fixed price agreement, contractors may be compelled to pursue evaluation of claims based on changes resulting in disputes over money and time. The establishment of a contract baseline, including a defined scope, schedule and conditions of work, can set conditions that can help to formalise the consequences of changes made by the client that may justify additional compensation for the contractor.
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings
- Alternative dispute resolution for construction ADR.
- Arbitration in the construction industry.
- Contract claims in construction.
- Contract claims procedure.
- Dispute avoidance.
- Evaluation.
- Fixed price construction contract.
- Lump sum contract.
- Mediation in construction.
[edit] External resources
- LawTeacher.net, Evaluation and Preparation of Claims in Construction Projects.
- John Mullen and Peter Davison, Evaluating Contract Claims.
- Society of Construction Law.
Featured articles and news
ECA Industry Awards 2024 shortlist revealed
22 leading businesses from across the electrotechnical and engineering services sector.
Government unveils Skills England strategy
Skills England to transform opportunities and drive growth.
New Government Hub for York Given Planning Green Light
For up to 2,600 civil servants, due for completion by 2028.
Construction Skills Certification Scheme cards
July update on Professionally Qualified and Academically Qualified Person Cards.
BSRIA Briefing 2024, November 22
Sustainable Futures: Redefining Retrofit for Net Zero Living.
The CLC on driving competency in the retrofit sector
Previously published roadmap on skills for net zero.
The first labour government King's speech in fifteen years
Construction industry reactions, support and some concern.
CIOB Retrofit of Buildings Technical Information Sheet
What retrofit is, the approach to be taken and processes to be followed.
Adapting Historic Buildings for Energy and Carbon Efficiency
Historic England advice note 18, free download published.
10 retrofit projects revisited 10 years after completion.
Information orders, building liability orders and SPVs
Key BSA terms and how they impact special purpose vehicles.
Listed despite problems with its design.
Zen and the art of cycling exploration.
Design Council Homes Taskforce launched
To support government 1.5 million homes target within UK climate commitments.