The British Mosque: an architectural and social history
The British Mosque: an architectural and social history.
Shahed Saleem, Historic England, 2018, 340 pages, 350 illustrations, hardback.
This is the story of some 1,500 mosques in Britain, their history, evolution, numbers, geographic distribution, architectural typologies, styles, patterns of growth and urban settings. As a result of an English Heritage / Historic England project, the book skilfully tells an intriguing narrative that goes beyond the dry comprehensive survey.
What is a mosque? What happens between the walls of one? Why do some mosques have domes and minarets, while others do not? What is the difference between Sunni and Shi’ah Muslims? How are differences among Muslim sects reflected in the architecture of their mosques?
Saleem’s book answers all these questions and more by contextualising the British mosque. It tells the stories of Muslims’ 130 years search for their identity as Brits. Some were migrants from Muslim countries. Others were British-born white, or people of colour who converted to Islam. Besides housing their religious, cultural and social needs, the mosque expressed Muslims’ identity and announced their presence by adding a new layer to the diversity of the British cityscape.
The appearance of the mosque in British cities was not always a smooth process. Most mosques were not built before going through various adaptations of design proposals and tough negotiations because of objections by non-Muslim local communities, or in response to refusals by local authorities’ architects and planners. The 70 years it took to realise Regent Park Mosque is perhaps an extreme example of such a complicated and lengthy process.
Purpose-built mosques express the different phases and generations of British Muslims’ search for their identity as both British and Muslim. On the other hand, mosques that were adaptations of existing buildings tell a rich story of organic growth of Muslim communities’ confidence and endeavours to establish their place in Britain.
British mosques are a fascinating catalogue of adaptive reuse of houses, churches, synagogues, schools, warehouses, nightclubs, public houses, dance halls, bingo halls, cinemas, casinos, libraries and fire stations, among other buildings. It is also a catalogue of conservation practices. Brick Lane Mosque is an interesting example of interventions in a Grade II listed building that observed conservation ethics: ‘Through its positioning and its contemporary styling, the minaret carefully negotiates the issue of not altering a historic and listed building to such a degree that its original character is compromised, while nevertheless identifying the Islamic use of the building. It functions, therefore, as street sculpture as much as specifically a signifier of the mosque.’
Brick Lane Mosque is a wonderful example of the diversity of religious faiths and immigrant histories in London. It used to be a Huguenot church, a Christian missionary school, a Wesleyan Methodist chapel, and a Jewish school and synagogue, before it became a mosque in 1976. Understandably, a photograph of its minaret is chosen for the book jacket.
This article originally appeared as ‘A search for identity’ in IHBC's Context 157 (Page 62), published in November 2018. It was written by Hossam Mahdy, international freelance consultant on the conservation of Islamic built heritage.
Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
Jacqueline Hughes, senior risk analyst at Equib, in pbctoday discusses how project managers for town centre developments can get their risk management strategies right.
A new paper from the Adam Smith Institute argues that the problem with the High Street has been totally misunderstood, saying that we need to reform restrictive planning rules and reject a policy of managed decline to reinvigorate our town centres.
The Whole Life Cost of Energy (WLCoE) calculator – issued by government in BETA form – is intended to help building owners and operators to understand the full financial cost of the energy their buildings use, and welcomes feedback
New research published by Historic England (HE) shows the value of heritage to England’s economy as it contributes to economic prosperity and growth through jobs in the heritage and construction sectors and from tourism.
Investigations have begun into what caused part of Chester’s Roman city wall to collapse during construction work.
Though conservation professionals' skills in understanding, defining and explaining local character and architecture can help inform new residential design.
Over 500 historic places have been added to the National Heritage List for England (NHLE) in 2019 and Historic England (HE) has showcased 21 highlights.
The K2 prototype telephone box situated outside the Royal Academy in London – built as part of the 1924 competition that gave rise to the iconic design and first listed at Grade II in 1986 – has had its listing upgraded to Grade II*.
The second in a series focusses on developing the Asset Information Model (AIM).
Reflecting issues that will be encountered across the IHBC’s June 2020 Brighton School, think tank Centre for Cities argues for High Street success.
City A.M took a tour of the first apartment to be completed within the original grade II*-listed power station with designer Tim Boyd of Michaelis Boyd – which also designed the interiors for Soho House and the Groucho Club – and Battersea Power Station’s UK sales director Georgia Siri.
A conversion of a locomotive hangar into a public library is the first retrofit to win the top prize at the World Architecture Festival (WAF).