Hybrid assured shorthold tenancy
In January 2017, in a decision that will be required reading for property landlords, the Court of Appeal has confirmed the validity of a form of assured shorthold tenancy that has been in common use for many years. At the same time, the Court defined the concept of ‘ownership’ in the context of council tax liabilities.
The case of Leeds City Council v Broadley concerned a property investor who rented out residential premises to tenants on the basis of standard form leases that are ubiquitous in the private rental sector. Each lease was for a term of six or 12 months and thereafter continued on a month-by-month basis. The obligation to pay council tax rested on the tenant.
Putting forward a novel argument, a local authority submitted that leases must either be for a fixed or a periodic term and that ‘hybrid’ leases are invalid. It was submitted that the lease concerned in the case had to be viewed either as for a fixed term, followed by a periodic tenancy, or as a monthly periodic tenancy that could not be terminated in its first six or 12 months.
On that basis, the council argued that the lease had not been granted for a period of six months or more and that relevant tenants could thus not be viewed as ‘owners’ within the meaning of Section 6 of the Local Government Finance Act 1992. That, it was submitted, meant that when a tenant ceased to occupy a property during the term of the lease, the liability to pay Council Tax reverted to the landlord.
In rejecting those arguments and dismissing the council’s appeal against an earlier decision to like effect, the Court found that the form of lease in question was valid. Such leases reflected an obvious commercial reality and provided a benefit to both landlord and tenant in offering a degree of initial certainty with a degree of flexibility thereafter.
[edit] Find out more
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
Featured articles
Check out some of the best features and news from Designing Buildings as well as key stories from around the web.
World's first mass timber data centre.
The overlooked environmental aspect of data centre development.
Introduction to radon awareness
New technical information sheet published by CIOB.
Updated supplier guide can help electrical contractors engage with NHP.
CIAT confirm the winners of the 2026 architectural technology awards.
Government launches a one stop shop for flood preparedness.
Sir Edwin Lutyens: Britain's greatest architect? Book review.
CIOB publishes free template to help assess and manage risks.
ECA's reflections on Party Conference season
Burnham wants to be confident of winning before asking for a fresh mandate.
New Chief Construction and Scientific Adviser
Sergio Cavalaro, Professor of Infrastructure Systems at Loughborough University.
Building safety levy for England
CIAT publish estimator tool for members.
Water sector faces a growing crisis that could slow the delivery of vital infrastructure.
Undervaluing our industrial past
Heritage value changes as taste for building styles changes.