Investment in training in the UK has fallen over the last 20 years, and it is thought this is harming productivity, with UK GDP per hour worked 17% lower than the average for the rest of the G7 and 30% lower than the US and Germany. The government points to research that indicates for every pound invested in adult apprenticeships at Level 2 and Level 3, the country benefits by £26 and £28 respectively.
 Apprenticeships levy
In the 2015 Emergency Budget, the Government announced that it would introduce a levy on large employers to help fund 3 million new apprenticeships by 2020. It was suggested that the apprenticeship levy would be introduced in April 2017 to increase investment in training and apprenticeships and create a ‘level the playing field’ so every big company plays their part. Ref PM unveils plans to boost apprenticeships and transform training.
Skills Minister Nick Boles said, “Skilled people are the lifeblood of a strong economy but for too long UK businesses have invested too little in developing their employees’ skills to meet the demands of a competitive, global market. The apprenticeship levy will ensure that businesses invest in skills and training, and will act as a much needed shot in the arm for the country’s productivity.”
However, in March 2017, the cross-party sub-committee on Education, Skills and the Economy criticised the scheme, saying, “We recommend that the government, as part of its continuing review of the operation of the levy, consider whether a single rate is the best approach and explore ways of restructuring the levy on a sectoral and regional basis…. The government has not set out how its increase in apprenticeship numbers will help fill the country’s skills gaps. The current balance of provision is skewed towards sectors with low wage returns and few skills shortages and we are not convinced that tinkering will bring about the major changes necessary.”
Despite this, the levy went live in April 2017. It applies to all ‘large’ employers, with an annual salary bill of more than £3m, who have an online 'voucher account' showing their levy contribution and digital vouchers they can use to purchase apprenticeship training. In addition, there is a requirement to take a company’s apprenticeship offer into account when awarding large government contracts.
Julia Evans, Chief Executive, BSRIA, said: “Apprenticeships provide the backbone for a career in engineering for many employees and no compromises should be made regarding them... In essence: the levy must meet industry and apprenticeship needs."
However, BSRIA suggested that industry concerns included:
- Some firms face paying for the levy but being unable to access new or updated training standards, or have no approved providers available locally.
- A lack of accessible information for employers about the government’s list of approved providers and their quality of training.
- Ineffective careers guidance in schools about available apprenticeship options.
In June 2018, the Federation of Master Builders suggested that the levy was not working, and called for a re-think. FMB chief executive Brian Berry said; “The government’s own statistics show a 28% per cent plunge in apprenticeship starts over the current academic year so far. The Apprenticeship Levy was introduced in April 2017 to boost apprenticeship training across all business sectors but so far it seems to be having the opposite effect.”
 NAO report into the apprenticeships programme
In March 2019, during National Apprenticeship Week, the National Audit Office (NAO) published ‘The apprenticeships programme’, assessing whether the apprenticeships levy programme provides value for money.
It found that the programme has shifted its focus towards delivering quality and meeting employers’ needs and that it has a better, more holistic approach to assessing its benefits. However, employers have only made limited use of the available funds to support new apprenticeships, and there has been a large drop in apprenticeship starts. It also reported a risk that the programme is simply subsidising training that would have happened anyway.
In addition, the NAO expressed concern about the long-term sustainability of the programme. Spending is driven by employers’ decisions about how many and what types of apprenticeships they want. This leaves the programme exposed to the risk that the budget may be insufficient. The government would then need to choose between providing more funding, restricting growth, or reducing the funding for some apprenticeships.
 Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
- 2015 Emergency Budget.
- Achieving carbon targets and bridging the skills gap.
- Apprenticeships come of age.
- Boardroom to building site skills gap survey.
- BSRIA calls on industry to get involved with National Apprenticeship Week 2019.
- Can apprenticeships solve the construction skills crisis?
- Construction Industry Training Board.
- Mixed news from the Perkins Review.
- National Infrastructure Plan for Skills.
- New apprenticeship levy.
- New apprentice levy funding model.
- Opening the door to apprenticeships for all.
- Perkins review of engineering skills.
- Protection for apprenticeships.
- Skills shortage.
- Skills to build (November 2014 report).
- Tackling the construction skills shortage (KLH Sustainability blog post November 2014).
Diversity, social value and skills
- Building People 'Network of Networks'
 Join in
Building People is bringing together the huge amount of resource that exists across the Built Environment industry, with a focus on diversity and inclusion, skills and careers, and social value.
We need your help to do this.
Have you got useful material to share? Do you know of information that would be helpful to others? If it is relevant to the Built Environment and to diversity, skills and social value, then it's relevant to others. Help them find it by using the guidelines below.
 Add your own content
- For guidance about writing and adding your own content see Get started - top tips and help.
- Some articles are more popular and useful than others. This article explains more.
- Make sure you use the right title as this helps search engines find it. See here for guidance.
- Add your signature to link readers to your profile.
- Tick the 'People' box when you submit the article - that way your content will appear in this Building People microsite.