Government procurement post-Carillion
In March 2020, the well-regarded Institute for Government (IfG) think tank held an event to mark the launch of a report looking into Government outsourcing and procurement post the collapse of Carillion.
Construction giant Carillion fell into liquidation in January 2018. Prior to this, Carillion had been one of the Government’s largest suppliers, undertaking a range of work of construction and facilities management activity, across various sectors.
However, an inquiry from the Business and the Work and Pensions Select Committees later found its collapse was "a story of recklessness, hubris and greed, its business model was a relentless dash for cash."
In fact, Carillion owed its suppliers and subcontractors hundreds of millions of pounds. Much of this was either payment due for completed work, or retentions held on work already undertaken. The suppliers never received their money back.
So, two years on, the Institute for Government sought to review how the Government is now approaching outsourcing, and what still needs to change.
On the day, a panel consisting of IfG (Tom Sasse and Nick Davies), CBI (Liz Crowhurst, Head of Infrastructure) and Shaw Trust (Chris Luck, CEO) discussed the findings of the report.
The panellists concurred that the principles of the Government's ‘outsourcing playbook’, developed after the collapse of Carillion, were sound. However, it was found that these principles are not yet being universally applied throughout Government.
The report also made a number of sensible recommendations, notably:
- Name a Cabinet Office minister who is responsible for improvements in outsourcing.
- Use this summer’s spending review to give the Cabinet Office funding to support and scrutinise contracting by departments.
- Extend contracting training to local government, the NHS, and other public bodies.
- Equip the new Audit, Reporting and Governance Authority with the statutory powers recommended by the Kingman review, including to force changes in company accounts rather than applying to court to do so.
These are sensible reforms which have the support of ECA, alongside the Government’s new requirement to remove late payers from the tendering process.
However, as report author Tom Sasse commented, "the race to the bottom on price is probably the biggest problem we have in contracting". Looking ahead, how the Government approaches this challenging issue will be fundamental to whether we see real change in procurement.
Our hope and expectation is that the Government will accelerate implementation of the Construction Leadership Council’s Business Model’s workstream output on Procuring for Value. This industry collaboration focused on the creation and establishment of a procurement model focused on the whole-life cost of the built asset, not just the construction cost.
In which case, procurement could finally be based on value rather than price…
You can view the report here - https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/sites/default/files/publications/carillion-two-years-on.pdf
This article was originally published on the ECA blog on 13 March 2020. It was written by Rob Driscoll, Director of Legal & Business at ECA.
--ECA
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
Featured articles and news
Key takeaways from the BSRIA Briefing 2024
Not just waiting for Net Zero, but driving it.
The ISO answer to what is a digital twin
Talking about digital twins in a more consistent manner.
Top tips and risks to look out for.
New Code of Practice for fire and escape door hardware
Published by GAI and DHF.
Retrofit of Buildings, a CIOB Technical Publication
Pertinent technical issues, retrofit measures and the roles involved.
New alliance will tackle skills shortage in greater Manchester
The pioneering Electrotechnical Training and Careers Alliance.
Drone data at the edge: three steps to better AI insights
Offering greater accuracy and quicker access to insights.
From fit-out to higher-risk buildings.
Heritage conservation in Calgary
The triple bottom line.
College of West Anglia apprentice wins SkillELECTRIC gold.
Scottish government launch delivery plan
To strengthen planning and tackle the housing emergency.
How people react in ways which tend to restore their comfort.
Comfort is a crucial missing piece of the puzzle.
ECA launches Recharging Electrical Skills Charter in Wales
Best solutions for the industry and electrical skills in Wales.
New homebuilding skills hub launch and industry response
Working with CITB and NHBC to launch fast track training.