Building a Crossing Tower: a design for Rouen Cathedral of 1516
Building a Crossing Tower: a design for Rouen Cathedral of 1516, by Costanza Beltrami, Paul Holberton publishing, 2016, 135 pages, 97 black and white and colour illustrations, paperback. |
The sum total of all surviving medieval gothic architectural drawings is no more than 600, of which barely 15 remain from all gothic France. The discovery in 2014 of a previously unknown drawing of a gothic tower with an immense, soaring spire was therefore an unusual event. The drawing, which is an impressive 3.5 metres in height, corresponds to no surviving gothic tower, and bears no signature or identifying title. What is also extraordinary is the top-down perspective from which the tower is represented, something that is not paralleled in any other medieval drawing.
The drawing is the subject of this absorbing book, in course of which Costanza Beltrami’s diligent research has enabled her to reveal its date, subject and probable designer. Moreover, she provides a wealth of fascinating information about the political and civic context in which the project was devised and the practice of late gothic architects. It concerns the final phase of the gothic style, known in France as the style Flamboyant, shortly before it was displaced by renaissance classicism.
The churches, chateaux and town halls of this period are not well known in Britain, but they represent some of the most thrilling architectural creations of the late middle ages in Europe, of which the drawing is a supreme example. The tower as depicted is a kind of fantasy, bristling with pinnacles, gargoyles and statues, and smothered in floral decoration, its spindly structure appearing to defy gravity. The book begins with a series of huge double-spread enlargements of sections of the drawing, which emphasise the compelling power of the design.
By extraordinarily good fortune, Beltrami has been able to attribute the drawing to Rouen Cathedral on the basis of surviving Chapter minutes. These record that following the destruction of an earlier crossing tower by fire in 1514, the cathedral canons held a competition for a replacement. Unsure which scheme to select, the Chapter sought advice from artisans and local citizens, eventually deciding on a compromise by which the ruined tower stonework would be repaired and finished off with a timber spire. This instruction, however, was ignored by the cathedral architect Roulland le Roux, who proceeded to build a stone tower to his own design.
When in due course this was found out, he claimed that his action was for the good of the cathedral. Another hiatus followed, with a new drawing produced by Roulland showing his intended design at first being accepted by the Chapter and then later rejected. The partially-built tower was duly capped off until it was completed 40 years later in the renaissance style. On the basis of the Chapter minutes, which are included as an appendix to the book, Beltrami has argued convincingly that the tower drawing is the one which Roulland submitted to the Chapter, and that its visionary character was intended to overcome the canons’ reluctance to permit him to continue.
To give context to this tale of intrigue and cultural ambition, Beltrami examines the use of architectural drawings in medieval Europe, the role of architects and craftsmen, and the commissioning process and associated political infighting. Written in a clear and engaging style, and beautifully illustrated with other comparable late-gothic drawings and buildings that are also little known, Building a Crossing Tower is a fascinating and informative book.
This article originally appeared as ‘Flamboyant fantasy’ in IHBC’s Context 155, published in July 2018. It was written by Peter de Figueiredo, heritage Consultant.
--Institute of Historic Building Conservation
Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
- Architectural styles.
- Cathedral.
- Conservation area.
- Conservation.
- Durham Cathedral's Open Treasure project.
- Floors of the great medieval churches.
- Gothic revival style
- Heritage.
- IHBC articles.
- Listed building.
- Machicolation.
- Scheduled monuments.
- The Institute of Historic Building Conservation.
- Types of drawing.
- Wimpole Gothic Tower conservation
IHBC NewsBlog
Bookings open for IHBC Annual School 12-15 June 2024
Theme: Place and Building Care - Finance, Policy and People in Conservation Practice
Rare Sliding Canal Bridge in the UK gets a Major Update
A moveable rail bridge over the Stainforth and Keadby Canal in the Midlands in England has been completely overhauled.
'Restoration and Renewal: Developing the strategic case' Published
The House of Commons Library has published the research briefing, outlining the different options for the Palace of Westminster.
Brum’s Broad Street skyscraper plans approved with unusual rule for residents
A report by a council officer says that the development would provide for a mix of accommodation in a ‘high quality, secure environment...
English Housing Survey 2022 to 2023
Initial findings from the English Housing Survey 2022 to 2023 have been published.
Audit Wales research report: Sustainable development?
A new report from Audit Wales examines how Welsh Councils are supporting repurposing and regeneration of vacant properties and brownfield sites.
New Guidance Launched on ‘Understanding Special Historic Interest in Listing’
Historic England (HE) has published this guidance to help people better understand special historic interest, one of the two main criteria used to decide whether a building can be listed or not.
"Conservation Professional Practice Principles" to be updated by IHBC, HTVF, CV
IHBC, HTVF, and CV look to renew this cross-sector statement on practice principles for specialists working in built and historic environment conservation roles.
Context No 177 Issued - Themed on working with Glass
Topics range from Manchester Cathedral’s stained glass to the long reign of Vitrolite, plus the IHBC North-West Branch conference and more.
Part of historic Old Courthouse in Cockermouth collapses into river
A section has fallen away and landed in the River Cocker below, including the back walls over three floors, sections of flooring and parts of the roof.