Fee for intervention FFI
In 2012, the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) introduced a fee for intervention (FFI) scheme which allows them to charge companies where safety breaches are found. If the HSE undertakes inspections and no material breaches are found, or the company is compliant, no charges are made.
An independent review of the fee for intervention scheme was undertaken in 2013 which found that its application had been successful and there was no ‘viable alternative’ which could meet the aim of shifting the cost of regulating work place health and safety away from the taxpayer to those who break the law.
It is only necessary for a charge to be levied on a company when a material breach is found. This is considered to be where there has been a contravention of health and safety law that requires a notice in writing to be issued.
The fee for intervention is applicable to all dutyholders where the HSE is the enforcing body. This includes:
- Employers.
- Self-employed individuals who may put others at risk.
- Individuals acting in a capacity other than as an employee, such as partners.
- Public and limited companies.
- Crown and public bodies.
- General, limited and limited liability parternships.
A material breach of the law is charged at £154 per hour and the total number of hours charged is based on the time it takes to identify the breach and remedy it.
In October 2015 it was reported that invoices issued to construction companies under the scheme for costs recovery had increased by 40% in the three years since it was introduced. See 40% increase in HSE cost recovery invoices for more information.
In September 2016, OCS Group won the right to a judicial review of the way the HSE handles FFI appeals, on the basis that they are acting as prosecutor, judge and jury.
In January 2017 it was revealed that fees had reached £15m in 2016, up 23% on the year before.
Also in January 2017, it was reported that the nature of the scheme would be questioned at a judicial review brought by facilities management firm OCS. This is seen as an attempt to have the fees bill overturned and the system for deciding appeals quashed.
In February 2017, proposals were put forward for an impartial body to rule on disputes over fees. An HSE spokesperson said; “HSE has always kept the dispute process under review and following a recent application for a judicial review we believe the time is right to move to a dispute process which is completely independent of HSE.”
In March 2017, it was reported that changes would include; a right for dutyholders to obtain evidence used by HSE; an independent appeals panel and a right to make submissions to the appeals panel. The changes must be in place by 1 September 2017 to avoid further court action.
In April 2017, HSE began a consultation into the proposed changes. The consultation closed on 2 June 2017. Following the consultation, HSE launched a revised process for considering disputes of invoices issued under the fee for intervention scheme. This involves all disputes being considered by a panel independent of HSE.
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki.
- Asbestos.
- CDM Regulations.
- Health and safety offences, corporate manslaughter and food safety and hygiene offences definitive guideline.
- COSHH.
- Deleterious materials.
- Demolition.
- HSE land use planning pre-application advice service.
- Health and safety.
- Health and safety inspector.
- Notify HSE.
- Reporting accidents and injuries on construction sites.
- Statutory consultee.
Featured articles and news
Expert taskforce to spearhead new, new town generation
Sir Michael Lyons given 12 months for recommendations.
Government policy statement on new towns
A coded vision for a new generation of new towns.
AT Principal Designer exemplars published
Supporting clear and comprehensive demonstration of the skills required.
Homes England goes to TOWN for co-housing project
Marmalade Lane developer selected for Northstowe neighbourhood.
Cohousing and related approaches to solve housing issues
Different forms of community housing explained with examples.
Alternative and off-grid housing communities in the UK
From Hockerton Housing Project to Tinkers Bubble.
Skills gap highlighted to Minister for Industry
Key opportunity in mission for economic growth and net-zero.
World Green Building Week 9-13 September
Join in the 16th annual event led by the World GBC.
Specifying XPS in masonry cavity walls below DPC level
Moisture requirements, DPCs and third party certification.
Types of rigid foam insulation
A brief description and some of the main construction types.
Metal composite material panel systems MCM and MCP
Sandwich finishes, forms, details, core and their impacts.
Cumbria's vernacular architecture
A history of building impeded by unsettled times.
CIOB and MMC Ireland announce strategic partnership
For better working conditions, and a more productive construction sector.
Grenfell Phase 2 final report for construction, at a glance
Twenty-three key issues raised and their recommendations.
Approved Document B: Fire Safety upcoming updates
Including sprinklers in care homes, National classes and Fire resistance.
Tools and processes supporting a robust golden thread
BSRIA Handover Information and O&M Manuals guidance.