Comparable rent accusation
Making comparisons between similar properties is the standard means of assessing appropriate levels of rent payable on commercial premises.
In the case of Clear Call Limited v Central London Investments Limited, the practice came under scrutiny by the Court of Appeal as a landlord defeated claims that it had entered into a sham lease at an artificially inflated rent in an attempt to push up its returns on other properties that it owned.
One of the landlord’s tenants had made an unopposed application for a new lease under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 but objected when the rent payable was fixed by a judge at £125,700 per annum. The judge had in part based his decision on the rent achieved by the same landlord in respect of another property.
The tenant argued that that transaction was a sham and that the comparison put forward by the landlord was artificial and unreal. It was said that the relevant premises had remained empty and in a dilapidated state since the rent was said to have been agreed and that the tenant was a dormant, non-trading, company.
The landlord denied the accusation that it had engaged in a ruse in an attempt to force up rents in an area in which it had substantial property holdings. The evidence showed that the transaction had taken place, that there had been negotiations prior to the grant of the lease and that rent had been paid.
In dismissing the tenant’s appeal, the Court noted that its arguments had been fully considered, and rejected, by the judge. Fresh evidence of alleged skulduggery that the tenant sought to put forward could either have been presented to the judge or was of no real substance. An appeal by the tenant had also previously been dismissed by the High Court.
[edit] Find out more
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
Featured articles and news
Protective construction clothing for women
It shouldn't be so difficult to find PPE that fits properly.
Pivoting infrastructure technology stands up to the test of time.
Report on the construction sector in Ireland
TASC/CIOB study looks at post-pandemic struggles and trends.
Revised targets for Carbon Budget 6
The Government announces recalibrated goals.
ECA proposes strategies for the present and the future.
Paul Morrell to lead independent review of the construction products testing regime.
Standard will help employers foster wellbeing and manage psychosocial risks.
The United Nations has approved the IFSS common principles
Global fire standards for safety of people and property.
An introduction to the 5 core principles of lean.
Civil engineers and environmental methods of construction
Can the profession use its skills to save the world from climate change?
How faulty science resulted in sanitation reform.
Conserving the Hilda Besse Building
Improving facilities, accessibility and overall appearance.
BSRIA IAQ topic guide published
Free download of TG 12/2021 available.
Electrotechincal mentors wanted
TESP works with The Youth Group to form skill sharing network.
Receive the Designing Buildings newsletter
Click the button to subscribe.