Set off in construction contracts
Set off (sometimes called contra charging) is a legal process by which party A defends a claim brought by party B, by A setting off in extinction or diminution of B’s claim, claims which A alleges against B.
For example:
- A client might reclaim the cost of water damage to their property caused by a contractor fitting out the floor above the damaged area.
- A contractor might set off costs against a sub-contractor that caused damage to finished work adjacent to the working area of the sub-contractor.
- In the case of late completion a client might set off the appropriate amount of liquidated and ascertained damages in accordance with the contract.
Whilst set off is often accompanied by a counterclaim it is to be distinguished in that set off cannot, unlike a counterclaim, give rise to a positive balance of claim.
Set off rights can either be contractual, equitable or in the case of insolvency, statutory.
Contractual set off will depend on the wording of the agreement between the parties. It is possible for contractual set off rights to extend to a wide range of different contracts, but the wording must be clear. Equitable set off arises by operation of law if there is sufficient proximity and connection between the parties (e.g. the same parties, site and project). A recent statement of the law of equitable set off is given in the Court of Appeal judgement in Geldof Metaalconstructie NV v Simon Carves Ltd [2010].
If a contracting party becomes insolvent, the Insolvency Act 1986 Section 323 (bankruptcy) and the Insolvency Rules Rule 4.90 (liquidation) provide for a statutory set off known as ‘mutual credits and mutual debits’.
This statutory set off requires account to be taken between the insolvent party and the proving creditor of mutual debts, mutual credits and mutual dealings arising before the insolvency which are then set off leaving only the balance, if any, provable in the insolvency. This is, of course, only fair as otherwise the creditor would be 100% liable on debts due to the insolvent and only receive the relevant distribution (often nothing) on debts owed by the insolvent.
In construction contracts, rights of set off and withholding payments are regulated by the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996 Part II Section 111, amended, with effect from October 2011, by the Local Democracy, Economic Development and Construction Act 2009 Part 8 Section 144. These Acts regulate the contents and prescribed periods for 'pay less' notices which must be served if a party wishes to deduct sums from amounts otherwise due under the contract.
Adjudication procedures constrain the effect of set off to preserve the public policy of adjudication that it should be a relatively speedy interim solution. In M J Gleeson Group Plc v Devonshire Green Holding Ltd [2004], the court held that a respondent could not set off claims arising after the commencement of the adjudication to avoid payment of a sum awarded by the adjudicator.
See also Section 111 (4) Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act.
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
- Abatement.
- Adjudication.
- Alternative dispute resolution.
- Contract.
- Contract conditions.
- Counterclaim.
- Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act.
- Liquidated and ascertained damages.
- Mediation.
- Scheme for Construction Contracts.
[edit] External references
Featured articles and news
The UK’s largest air pollution campaign.
Future Homes Standard, now includes solar, but what else?
Will the new standard, due to in the Autumn, go far enough in terms of performance ?
BSRIA Briefing: Cleaner Air, Better tomorrow
A look back at issues relating to inside and outside air quality, discussed during the BSRIA briefing in 2023.
Restoring Abbotsford's hothouse
Bringing the writer Walter Scott's garden to life.
Reflections on the spending review with CIAT.
Retired firefighter cycles world to raise Grenfell funds
Leaving on 14 June 2025 Stephen will raise money for youth and schools through the Grenfell Foundation.
Key points for construction at a glance with industry reactions.
Functionality, visibility and sustainability
The simpler approach to specification.
Architects, architecture, buildings, and inspiration in film
The close ties between makers and the movies, with our long list of suggested viewing.
SELECT three-point plan for action issued to MSPs
Call for Scottish regulation, green skills and recognition of electrotechnical industry as part of a manifesto for Scottish Parliamentary elections.
UCEM becomes the University of the Built Environment
Major milestone in its 106-year history, follows recent merger with London School of Architecture (LSE).
Professional practical experience for Architects in training
The long process to transform the nature of education and professional practical experience in the Architecture profession following recent reports.
A people-first approach to retrofit
Moving away from the destructive paradigm of fabric-first.
International Electrician Day, 10 June 2025
Celebrating the role of electrical engineers from André-Marie Amperè, today and for the future.
New guide for clients launched at Houses of Parliament
'There has never been a more important time for clients to step up and ...ask the right questions'
The impact of recycled slate tiles
Innovation across the decades.
EPC changes for existing buildings
Changes and their context as the new RdSAP methodology comes into use from 15 June.
Comments