Assignment of construction contracts
Assignment is the right to transfer 'choses in action' defined as 'all personal rights of property which can only be claimed or enforced by action and not by taking physical possession'.
This definition includes benefits arising under a construction contract such as right to payment, but not burdens such as the obligation to pay. The definition also includes claims for breach of contract.
A common error is to assume that the right to assign must be agreed as part of a contract, like a novation. Assignment is a unilateral right created by statute, Section 136 of The Law of Property Act 1925 or by the law of equity (law developed by the Chancery Division of the High Court of England and Wales).
Whilst not a contractual right, the right to assign can be excluded, or restricted, by contract, for example, it is common in collateral warranties to restrict to one assignment without the written permission of the warrantor.
Under Section 136 of The Law of Property Act 1925 the formalities required to create an effective legal assignment are:
- An absolute (i.e. not part of a debt or by way of charge only) assignment in writing signed by the assignor.
- A debt or other legal right of action.
- Express notice in writing to the debtor (no particular form of wording is necessary).
An assignment which fails to comply with the above formalities may, nevertheless, still be effective as an equitable assignment. Indeed an equitable assignment may be verbal. There is no substantial difference between legal and equitable assignments (though, of course it will be easier to prove a legal assignment), there are, however, procedural differences.
The assignee of a legal assignment sues the debtor in the assignee's own name. The assignee of an equitable assignment of a legal chose in action or an equitable chose that is not absolute, must join the assignor (as claimant if the assignor agrees, or defendant if not ) into any legal proceedings.
The effect of a legal or equitable assignment is to put the assignee in the same position as the assignor in respect of the benefits (not burdens) arising from the original transaction with the debtor. Consequently:
'... a debt which accrues due before notice of assignment is received, whether or not it is payable before that date, or a debt which arises out of the same contract as that which gives rise to the assigned debt, or is closely connected with that contract, may be set off against the assignee.'
(Ref. Business Computers Ltd v Anglo African Leasing Ltd.)
A counterclaim for unliquidated damages may also be set off by the debtor, but only to the value of the assigned debt. Further when there have been successive assignments the debtor cannot set off against claims by the ultimate assignee, counterclaims which the debtor has against intermediate assignees.
The Scottish law equivalent is assignation.
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings
- Alienation covenant.
- Appointing consultants.
- Assignation.
- Assignment of choses in action.
- Assignment of debt.
- Construction contracts.
- Difference between assignment and novation.
- Difference between collateral warranties and third party rights.
- Legal and equitable assignment.
- Novation.
- Novation agreement.
- Privity of contract.
- Privity of title.
- Proprietary information.
- Recovery of third party losses.
- Reliance letter.
- Restrictions on assignment.
- Reverse premium.
- Set off.
- The Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act.
- Title.
- Warranty.
[edit] External references
Featured articles and news
Flexibility over requirements to boost apprentice numbers
English, maths and minimumun duration requirements reduced for a 10,000 gain.
A long term view on European heating markets
BSRIA HVAC 2032 Study.
Humidity resilience strategies for home design
Frequency of extreme humidity events is increasing.
National Apprenticeship Week 2025
Skills for life : 10-16 February
Update on the future of Grenfell Tower
Deputy Prime Minister decides for it be carefully taken down to the ground.
Ending decades of frustration, misinformation and distrust.
Essential tools in managing historically significant landscapes.
Classroom electrician courses a 'waste of money'
Say experts from the Electrical Contractors’ Association.
Wellbeing in Buildings TG 10/2025
BSRIA topic guide updates.
With brief background and WELL v2™.
From studies, to books to a new project, with founder Emma Walshaw.
Types of drawings for building design
Still one of the most popular articles the A-Z of drawings.
Who, or What Does the Building Safety Act Apply To?
From compliance to competence in brief.
The remarkable story of a Highland architect.
Commissioning Responsibilities Framework BG 88/2025
BSRIA guidance on establishing clear roles and responsibilities for commissioning tasks.
An architectural movement to love or hate.
Don’t take British stone for granted
It won’t survive on supplying the heritage sector alone.
Comments