- Project plans
- Project activities
- Legislation and standards
- Industry context
Last edited 29 Sep 2014
Counterclaim in construction
A counterclaim is a claim set up in opposition to another claim, that is, a claim by a party against a another party who has made a claim against them. This is not a defence to a claim, it is separate from it and proceeds even if the original claim is ended.
Set off (or contra charging) is only permitted if a breach of contract by a party making a claim is so closely associated with the claim that it would not be just to consider the claim without also taking the breach into account (or where the claims are both for payment of readily ascertained debts).
Whilst set off is often accompanied by a counterclaim it is to be distinguished in that a counterclaim may be entirely different in nature to the claim, and set off, unlike a counterclaim, cannot give rise to a positive balance of claim whilst a counterclaim may exceed the amount of the initial claim.
Abatement argues that an amount claimed is incorrect because of defects in the work. If the defect is proved, then the valuation of the amount due may be reduced by the reduction in value of the works resulting from the defect.
Before the 2011 amendments to the Housing Grants Construction and Regeneration Act, set off and counterclaim were only permitted if a withholding notice was issued, whilst abatement did not require a withholding notice as the value of the works had been reduced and there was only an obligation to pay the amount properly due.
 Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
- Alternative dispute resolution.
- Housing Grants Construction and Regeneration Act.
- Set off.
 External references
- A Straume (UK) Ltd v Bradlor Developments Ltd.
- Urang Commercial v Century Investments and Eclipse Hotels (Luton).
- Whyte and Mackay Ltd v Blyth & Blyth Consulting Engineers.
Featured articles and news
From the decorative to the utilitarian, and from the photographed to the forgotten.
New BRE book considers the progression from project-based knowledge creation to whole-life urban knowledge management.
This CIOB article explores the concept of value in building design and construction.
BREEAM and Measurabl announce integration to improve the financial performance of commercial real estate.
Rogers Stirk Harbour + Partners' release new images of soon-to-open 3WTC tower in New York.
A document can be called a bond or a guarantee. Does the name matter and what is the difference between them?
New briefing note is launched focusing on increasing knowledge of housing that promotes health and wellbeing.
Arbitration is a private, contractual form of dispute resolution used in the construction industry.
The European Parliament has approved a revised Energy Performance of Buildings directive.
One in six MPs supports the ring-fencing of retentions as proposed in the 'Aldous Bill'.
A stakeholder is anyone who has an interest in the process or outcome of a construction project.