Service charge and 18 month rule
When it comes to issuing service charge demands, landlords must stick to the letter of leases or risk recovering nothing at all – even if that results in tenants receiving an unwarranted windfall.
In the case of Skelton v DBS Homes (Kings Hill) Limited [2017], the Court of Appeal made that point in relieving a residential tenant of liability to pay service charges over a four-year period.
Under the terms of the relevant lease, service charge demands were required to be accompanied by estimates of projected expenditure over the next year. No such estimates were included for four years. That oversight was later corrected, but the tenant argued that was not liable to pay the charges due to the landlord’s failure to comply with the terms of the lease.
The tenant’s arguments did not persuade the First-tier or Upper Tribunals. However, in allowing his appeal, the Court cited Section 20B of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985. That provision, often called the 18-month rule, requires that costs incurred by landlords more than 18 months prior to the service of demands for payment are not recoverable from tenants.
The Court found that the 18-month rule applies equally to demands for payment on account as to demands in respect of costs that have already been incurred. The purpose of the rule was to ensure that tenants receive proper demands for service charges within 18 months of the relevant costs being incurred.
That had not happened in the current case because the demands had not become valid until the estimates were also served on the tenant. If the outcome of the case resulted in the tenant receiving a windfall, that was a consequence of the landlord’s default.
[edit] Find out more
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
Featured articles and news
Conserving the Hilda Besse Building
Improving facilities, accessibility and overall appearance.
BSRIA IAQ topic guide published
Free download of TG 12/2021 available.
Electrotechincal mentors wanted
TESP works with The Youth Group to form skill sharing network.
OpenBuilt supply chain technology in development
Big tech collaborates on platform for the built environment.
Concerns raised over Future Buildings Standard
Letter signed by 21 organisations sent to MHCLG.
The infrastructure planning process
A look at the Government's strategic approach.
Steps to help reduce the spread of infection inside buildings.
Urban exploration and construction
This social media-centred hobby can be both dangerous and illegal.
Millwork wall treatment with a long and illustrious history.
Weekly workplace noise estimator tool
HSE introduces cumulative exposure calculator.
The Edwardians and their houses.
Cut off from civilian life for over 900 years.
Can net zero and levelling-up align?
Gaining green support from the carbon giants.
Receive the Designing Buildings newsletter
Click the button to subscribe.