Resorting to self-help in boundary dispute
Boundary and rights of way disputes can become extremely heated – but a recent Court of Appeal case clearly illustrated why those involved should never delay seeing a solicitor and should always refrain from taking the law into their own hands.
The case of Shaw v Grouby & Anr [2017] concerned two landowners who had owned a country estate on which they had obtained planning permission to build three new houses.
After selling on the estate, they retained ownership of a long driveway that provided the only means of access to the houses. The owner of one of them had built a wall around her property and installed a new gated entrance.
Convinced that she had trespassed on their property, the landowners resorted to self-help and deposited two large yellow plastic bins full of concrete so as to block the only vehicular access to her home. They moved the bins after the woman took legal action but they remained in a position that caused access difficulties.
In dismissing the landowners’ trespass claim, a judge subsequently found that they owned only the metalled surface of the drive, not its verges. He also ruled that the woman had a right to access her home through the new entrance and ordered the landowners to pay 95% of her very substantial legal costs.
The facts of the case emerged as the Court rejected the landowners’ appeal against those decisions, finding that they were correct in law.
The Court accepted that the judge had intervened more than he should have done during the trial, but found that the landowners had nevertheless received a fair hearing.
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
Featured articles and news
ECA Industry Awards 2024 shortlist revealed
22 leading businesses from across the electrotechnical and engineering services sector.
Government unveils Skills England strategy
Skills England to transform opportunities and drive growth.
New Government Hub for York Given Planning Green Light
For up to 2,600 civil servants, due for completion by 2028.
Construction Skills Certification Scheme cards
July update on Professionally Qualified and Academically Qualified Person Cards.
BSRIA Briefing 2024, November 22
Sustainable Futures: Redefining Retrofit for Net Zero Living.
The CLC on driving competency in the retrofit sector
Previously published roadmap on skills for net zero.
The first labour government King's speech in fifteen years
Construction industry reactions, support and some concern.
CIOB Retrofit of Buildings Technical Information Sheet
What retrofit is, the approach to be taken and processes to be followed.
Adapting Historic Buildings for Energy and Carbon Efficiency
Historic England advice note 18, free download published.
10 retrofit projects revisited 10 years after completion.
Information orders, building liability orders and SPVs
Key BSA terms and how they impact special purpose vehicles.
Listed despite problems with its design.
Zen and the art of cycling exploration.
Design Council Homes Taskforce launched
To support government 1.5 million homes target within UK climate commitments.