Poor drafting of agreements
Large sums of money can hinge on the interpretation of a very few words, which is why professional drafting of agreements is so important. That point was powerfully made in a High Court case concerning an option to purchase a commercial property.
In Helix 3D Limited v Dunedin Industrial Property Nominee Limited & Anr, the tenant of the property had paid £25,000 for the five-year option. It enabled the tenant to purchase the freehold for a fixed price of £1.5 million at any time during the first two years of the agreement.
In the following three years, the price payable was £1.5 million or the open market value, whichever was the greater.
In the fifth year of the option, shortly before it expired, the tenant purported to exercise it by offering £1.5 million and paying a £90,000 deposit. The landlord denied that the option had been validly exercised on the basis that there had been no agreement or determination of the open market value.
In ruling on the dispute, the Court noted that it was rooted in the poor drafting of the agreement. The landlord’s interpretation of the option was divorced from reality in that it would require the tenant to guess the open market value before seeking to exercise it. A reasonable person would not have expected the option to be modelled on a lottery. In finding that the option had been validly exercised, the Court concluded that the tenant’s interpretation made greater commercial sense.
[edit] Find out more
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
Featured articles and news
Heat pump announcements, what homeowners need to know
An 'ultimate guide to heat pumps' from a heating company.
Construction contract awards reach £7.1bn in February
Their highest level in seven months.
The journey to sustainability in heritage
Research is the key to better understanding.
Heritage approaches to adaptation, mitigation and loss.
Bridging the gap between policy, finance and installation.
Development on brownfield land
Definition, background, policy and the latest consultation.
With the Design Framework for Building Services.
Retrofit of Buildings, a CIOB Technical Publication
Pertinent technical issues, measures and the roles involved.
ECA joins HSE campaign to support mental health
Working Minds’ five simple steps based on risk assessment.
Mental health in the construction industry
Mental health issues in brief with related articles.
Transitional arrangements, Building Control and the BSR.
For pre-October buildings with substantial progress by April.
How to write an inspection and test plan
ITPs for quality control and assurance particular elements.
Why quality counts in domestic ventilation systems
From products, to systems to the installation.
Empowering the Future with CIOB Academy
Lifelong learning, upscaling, and reskilling for the built environment.
Winners of the 2024 ASBP Awards
Project, Product and Initiative according to the 6 pillars.