Gable House Estates Ltd v The Halpern Partnership and Another
In Gable House Estates Ltd v The Halpern Partnership and Another, Judge Esyr Lewis QC derived the following principles from Henderson and Others v Merrett Syndicates Ltd and Others:
- A concurrent duty in tort can exist where the parties are in a contractual relationship if the terms of the contract do not preclude it.
- That concurrent duty in tort will arise and enable a plaintiff to recover damages for economic loss where, for example, in a contract for services, certainly where the defendant has special knowledge or skills, the defendant assumes responsibility to the plaintiff. The assumption of responsibility to perform those services with due skill and care will arise from the very nature of the services which the defendant undertakes to provide.
- There must, however, be a 'concomitant reliance' by the plaintiff to enable them to establish their claim.
- ‘Reliance' may take different forms in different circumstances.
- The assumption of responsibility and the duty to take care is not confined to cases concerned with erroneous information and advice. For example, a solicitor may be liable if they fail to do something that it was their responsibility to do for their client, which causes loss. In this kind of situation, the fact that the solicitor had been retained and what they failed to do was within the scope of the duties their retainer required of them will be sufficient to establish reliance.
- However, where the complaint is that there has been negligent advice or negligent misinformation, the plaintiff must show that they specifically relied on that advice or were actually misled.
Principles 2 to 5 appear to some commentators to be 'propping open the rear window'. Certainly this was the view, albeit obiter, of Bedlam LJ in the case of Barclays Bank pic v Fairclough Building Ltd, where he stated:
'A skilled contractor undertaking maintenance work to a building assumes a responsibility which invites reliance no less than the financial or other professional adviser does in undertaking his work. The nature of the responsibility is the same though it will differ in extent... I would hold that [the sub-contractor] in performing the work ... sub-contracted to it owed a concurrent duty in tort to avoid causing economic loss by failing to exercise the care and skill of a competent contractor.’
By way of contrast, in Plant Construction plc v Clive Adams Associates and JHM Construction Services Ltd the court at first instance held that the facts of that case did not disclose a relationship which would give rise to any duty of care between a third party sub-contractor, JMH, and the employer, Ford. Judge Humphrey Lloyd QC considered that the imposition of a duty of care on the basis of an assumption of responsibility was wholly inconsistent with the contractual structure between employer and main contractor. The court was acting on the constraint enunciated by Lord Goff in Henderson and Others v Merrett Syndicates Ltd and Others. It would appears to some that the ratio in Junior Books Ltd v Veitchi Co Ltd is being 'laid to rest' slowly but with dignity.
[edit] Find out more
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
Featured articles and news
Latest Build UK Building Safety Regime explainer published
Key elements in one short, now updated document.
UKGBC launch the UK Climate Resilience Roadmap
First guidance of its kind on direct climate impacts for the built environment and how it can adapt.
CLC Health, Safety and Wellbeing Strategy 2025
Launched by the Minister for Industry to look at fatalities on site, improving mental health and other issues.
One of the most impressive Victorian architects. Book review.
Common Assessment Standard now with building safety
New CAS update now includes mandatory building safety questions.
RTPI leader to become new CIOB Chief Executive Officer
Dr Victoria Hills MRTPI, FICE to take over after Caroline Gumble’s departure.
Social and affordable housing, a long term plan for delivery
The “Delivering a Decade of Renewal for Social and Affordable Housing” strategy sets out future path.
A change to adoptive architecture
Effects of global weather warming on architectural detailing, material choice and human interaction.
The proposed publicly owned and backed subsidiary of Homes England, to facilitate new homes.
How big is the problem and what can we do to mitigate the effects?
Overheating guidance and tools for building designers
A number of cool guides to help with the heat.
The UK's Modern Industrial Strategy: A 10 year plan
Previous consultation criticism, current key elements and general support with some persisting reservations.
Building Safety Regulator reforms
New roles, new staff and a new fast track service pave the way for a single construction regulator.
Architectural Technologist CPDs and Communications
CIAT CPD… and how you can do it!
Cooling centres and cool spaces
Managing extreme heat in cities by directing the public to places for heat stress relief and water sources.
Winter gardens: A brief history and warm variations
Extending the season with glass in different forms and terms.
Restoring Great Yarmouth's Winter Gardens
Transforming one of the least sustainable constructions imaginable.