Employment status: a concise guide
![]() |
Recent court cases involving the likes of Uber, Deliveroo and Pimlico Plumbers mean that the topic of employment status is never far from the spotlight. This reflects the growing importance of new ways of working, such as in the so-called ‘gig economy’.
Keen to enlarge its revenue from income tax and national insurance contributions (NICs), the UK government has also been adopting a tougher line on employment status, ‘cracking down’ on various arrangements perceived to facilitate what is often termed ‘false self-employment’.
Organisations need to determine at the outset, ideally in writing, whether an individual is an employee, a worker or self-employed.
Contents |
[edit] Determining status
The three main factors (sometimes referred to as the ‘irreducible minimum’) that are normally considered by a court or an employment tribunal when determining an individual's employment status are as follows:
[edit] 1 Personal service
An employee/worker is required to provide their services personally. They cannot employ or engage staff to support themselves in doing so. In contrast, a self-employed person is not required to carry out the services personally and has an unfettered right to appoint substitutes or additional personnel.
[edit] 2 Mutuality of obligations
In an employment relationship, the employer is under an obligation to provide the employee with regular work, and the employee (quite often a worker, too) is under an obligation to do the work where provided. An organisation is not obliged to offer work to a self-employed person on a regular or frequent basis and that individual is not obliged to accept any work where offered.
[edit] 3 Control
An employee/worker is under the employer's control in terms of what they do, how they do it and when they do it, although professional or skilled individuals may exercise discretion over their own work and still be classed as employees. A self-employed individual is deemed to have the freedom to determine when and how they work and is not under the direct control or supervision of their client.
If all three of the above elements are present, the individual is likely to be an employee (or sometimes a ‘worker’). Tribunals normally look at the full picture, at the terms of the contract between the business and the individual, and how the arrangements operate in practice.
Other key indicators may be used to help determine whether an individual is employed or not. These can be found in the ECA’s Guidance Document on employment status (for ECA members only). Visit [[w/index.php?title=W/index.php%3Ftitle%3DW/index.php%3Ftitle%3DW/index.php%3Ftitle%3DW/index.php%3Ftitle%3DWww.eca.co.uk/business-industry-support/employee-relations%26action%3Dedit%26redlink%3D1%26action%3Dedit%26redlink%3D1%26action%3Dedit%26redlink%3D1%26action%3Dedit%26redlink%3D1&action=edit&redlink=1|www.eca.co.uk/business-industry-support/employee-relations]] for more.
[edit] About this article
This article was written by Orazio Amantia, Senior Employee Relations Advisor at the Electrical Contractors’ Association (ECA). It was first published on the ECA website in April 2019 and can be accessed here.
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings
- Equality Act.
- Equal opportunities policy.
- Gangmaster.
- Good Work Plan promises clearer contracts, fairer rules
- IR35.
- Non-productive overtime.
- PAYE.
- Payroll companies.
- Personal service company.
- Professional indemnity insurance.
- TUPE Regulations.
- Umbrella companies.
--ECA
Featured articles and news
Editor's broadbrush view on forms of electrical heating in context.
The pace of heating change; BSRIA market intelligence
Electric Dreams, Boiler Realities.
New President of ECA announced
Ruth Devine MBE becomes the 112th President of the Electrical Contractors Association.
New CIAT Professional Standards Competency Framework
Supercedes the 2019 Professional Standards Framework from 1 May 2025.
Difficult Sites: Architecture Against the Odds
Free exhibition at the RIBA Architecture Gallery until 31 May.
PPN 021: Payment Spot Checks in Public Sub-Contracts
Published following consultation and influence from ECA.
Designing Buildings reaches 20,000 articles
We take a look back at some of the stranger contributions.
Lessons learned from other industries.
The Buildings of the Malting Industry. Book review.
Conserving places with climate resilience in mind.
Combating burnout.
The 5 elements of seiri, seiton, seiso, seiketsu and shitsuke.
Shading for housing, a design guide
A look back at embedding a new culture of shading.
The Architectural Technology Awards
The AT Awards 2025 are open for entries!
ECA Blueprint for Electrification
The 'mosaic of interconnected challenges' and how to deliver the UK’s Transition to Clean Power.
Grenfell Tower Principal Contractor Award notice
Tower repair and maintenance contractor announced as demolition contractor.