Contra proferentem
Contra proferentem is a rule of construction applying to written documents or deeds. The rule provides that if the wording of an agreement is ambiguous or uncertain, but not otherwise, the contract should be construed more strongly against the person whose words they are rather than the other party.
In the case of John Lee & Son (Grantham) Ltd v Railway Executive (1949) it was found that:
'We are presented with two alternative readings of this document and the reading which one should adopt is to be determined, amongst other things, by a consideration of the fact that the defendants put forward the document. They have put forward a clause which is by no means free from obscurity and have contended... that it has a remarkably, if not extravagantly, wide scope and I think that the rule contra proferentem should be applied’
If a party has incorporated its own standard terms and conditions of trade into an agreement then in the event of ambiguity those terms and conditions will be construed contra proferentem that party. Where however the parties execute standard form contracts, the contra proferentem rule will only operate in respect of amendments or additions to the contract.
Contra proferentem is a particularly important rule of construction in relation to exclusion clauses.
[edit] Find out more
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings Wiki
Featured articles and news
This article examines the changing policy commitments and evolving definitions of the zero carbon home.
Researchers believe they may have created a 'game-changing' new form of concrete using graphene.
Grouting refers to the injection of materials into a soil or rock formation to change its physical characteristics.
Part of Designing Buildings Wiki, BREEAM Wiki will advance knowledge sharing for the BRE family of sustainability tools.
Iron, glass and wood underfoot
From the decorative to the utilitarian, and from the photographed to the forgotten.
New BRE book considers the progression from project-based knowledge creation to whole-life urban knowledge management.
This CIOB article explores the concept of value in building design and construction.
BREEAM and Measurabl announce integration to improve the financial performance of commercial real estate.
Rogers Stirk Harbour + Partners' release new images of soon-to-open 3WTC tower in New York.
A document can be called a bond or a guarantee. Does the name matter and what is the difference between them?
New briefing note is launched focusing on increasing knowledge of housing that promotes health and wellbeing.
Arbitration is a private, contractual form of dispute resolution used in the construction industry.