Ampurius Nu Homes Holdings Ltd v Telford Homes (Creekside) Ltd (2012) EWHC 1820
[edit] High Court (Chancery Division) (England and Wales) 2012
The claimant and the defendant (a construction company) entered into a contract for the construction and grant of long leases on a development scheme for which the defendant acquired the freehold. The defendant was required under the contract to proceed with 'due diligence' and to 'use reasonable endeavours' to complete the works by the target date. However, the defendant ran into financial difficulties ceased work.
The claimant alleged that this was a repudiatory breach, but did not terminate the contract for 11 months. It was the defendant who repudiated the contract.
Judgment was given in favour of the claimant.
In so doing, The court held that the defendant was in breach of the term of the contract requiring due diligence by failing to carry out the works assiduously or expeditiously. It was also held that although the breach may not have been repudiatory at the outset, it could become so over time if it deprived the innocent party of the benefit of a significant part of the contract. Negotiation over the course of the breach did not mean the claimant had affirmed the contract.
[edit] Court of Appeal (Civil Division) (England and Wales) 2013
In 2013 this decision was overturned by the Court of Appeal. It was not disputed that Telford had been in breach of contract, but the court held that an 18 month delay on a 999-year lease was not sufficient to constitute a repudiatory breach (a breach that it indicates one party no longer intends to accept its obligations under the contract, allowing the innocent party to terminate the contract and to sue for damages) and so did not entitle Ampurius to terminate the contract.
[edit] External references
Featured articles and news
Heritage protection in England vs Australia.
Fire doors and the Fire Door Inspection Scheme.
Three-quarters of fire doors fail inspections
UN International Day for Biological Diversity, May 22.
The role of geoparks, biospheres and world heritage sites.
BSRIA conference 2022, June 23.
Just one month to go ! Find out more here.
Restoring Broadbent’s Bath House
A new gallery for the University of Huddersfield.
Corruption in the construction industry.
What will it take to stop it ?
To celebrate world bee day 2022 !
Just one month until the changes to part L come into effect.
Not forgetting part F and the new part overheating part O.
Heat Pump demand rises by one quarter.
As energy prices jump up in cost.
With people in the UK from Ukraine.
Industry leader Steve Murray takes on role.
An abundant and versatile building material.
How overheating complicates ending gas in the UK.
600,000 heat pump installations targeted per year by 2028.
Cost planning, control and related articles on DB.
Helping prevent those unwanted outcomes.
ICE debate Public transport - post pandemic.
How has transport changed due to Covid-19 ?
Cross-ventilation in buildings. Do you have it ?
Will you need it ? after June 15 and the new Part O ?
Share your knowledge with the industry.
Create an account and write the first of many articles.
The green jobs delivery group.
CIAT commentary after the first meeting.
Liverpool's world heritage site status
Who is to blame?
Research recommends focussing on portfolio success rather than project success.