Fit for Purpose launch event
See also: Construction knowledge gap meeting and Knowledge gap survey responses.
On 21 September 2017, Designing Buildings Wiki held an event to launch a new report 'Fit for purpose?' exposing a worrying and widening knowledge gap in the construction industry.
Held in the spectacular 14th floor offices of Rogers Stirk Harbour + Partners in the Leadenhall Building, the report asks whether the construction knowledge base needs to change if it is to serve the industry properly.
Following an introduction by Designing Buildings Wiki chairman David Trench, Mark Farmer, the author of the government-commissioned report ‘Modernise or Die’, drew some parallels between the dramatic findings of his own report and the entrenched problems revealed by 'Fit for purpose'.
Farmer said:
“The findings of this report reaffirm that current knowledge and innovation is not being captured in a way that is broadly and strategically accessible to enable industry at large to benefit. Knowledge and data ‘silos’ are a feature of our industry and we clearly need to break these open through more collaborative forums and platforms that have greater reach into the mainstream of our industry.
“The assertion that much academic work is not influencing industry’s improvement is one that I identify with and we need a step up in the vetting of what research is commissioned that has sufficient applied value for the wider industry rather than specialist interest groups that does not necessarily make it relevant or scalable.”
Dr Gregor Harvie, co-founder of Designing Buildings Wiki, then took the audience through the ‘Fit for Purpose?’ report, laying out with stark clarity the exponential increase in the amount of knowledge the industry has to process and the accelerating rate at which knowledge changes.
He then showed a series of visual heat maps, based on 6 million pieces of data accumulated from users of Designing Buildings Wiki, which illustrate as never before that the knowledge framework underpinning the construction industry is no longer fit for purpose. Practitioners do not have easy access to the critical knowledge they need, and research is not having an impact on the ground - so it is inevitable that mistakes will be made.
“Knowledge buried in long documents or behind paywalls”, Dr Harvie said, “will not be used, even if it’s important.”
The report makes clear that industry's knowledge creators continue to focus on niche research aimed at making the top performing 1% of the industry better. But it is leaving the other 99% to fend for themselves.
The never-before-seen heat maps reveal the vast difference between the knowledge the industry wants and the knowledge that is actually on offer. They also show differences in knowledge consumption between the sexes and between age groups, and this information could be used to created targeted knowledge, for example, to encourage younger women to remain in the industry.
Dr Harvie went on to explain that the average dwell time across all types of knowledge is just three minutes, with users increasingly accessing content on mobile devices. He suggested that if knowledge is not easily accessible, easy to apply, and free, the igeneration simply won't use it.
Highlighting the seriousness of the knowledge problem, Dr Harvie said:
“In the wake of the Edinburgh schools defects and the fallout from the Grenfell Tower tragedy, the report suggests the industry needs to get organised and stop leaving the dissemination of knowledge to chance - or more mistakes will be made.”
He proposed that the industry must co-ordinate to tackle knowledge as a whole, rather than piecemeal, and that new funding mechanisms are necessary to reward practitioners for contributing to the industry knowledge base, rather than just professional researchers.
To read more about the findings of the report and to download a copy, see Fit for Purpose?
Watch Gregor Harvie talking at the launch event.
Watch Mark Farmer talking at the launch event.
[edit] Designing Buildings Wiki would like to thank all those who attended the event and our sponsors Rogers Stirk Harbour + Partners for generously hosting us in their offices.
Featured articles and news
Ministers to unleash biggest building boom in half a century
50 major infrastructure projects, 5 billion for housing and 1.5 million homes.
RIBA Principal Designer Practice Note published
With key descriptions, best practice examples and FAQs, with supporting template resources.
Electrical businesses brace for project delays in 2025
BEB survey reveals over half worried about impact of delays.
Accelerating the remediation of buildings with unsafe cladding in England
The government publishes its Remediation Acceleration Plan.
Airtightness in raised access plenum floors
New testing guidance from BSRIA out now.
Picking up the hard hat on site or not
Common factors preventing workers using head protection and how to solve them.
Building trust with customers through endorsed trades
Commitment to quality demonstrated through government endorsed scheme.
New guidance for preparing structural submissions for Gateways 2 and 3
Published by the The Institution of Structural Engineers.
CIOB launches global mental health survey
To address the silent mental health crisis in construction.
New categories in sustainability, health and safety, and emerging talent.
Key takeaways from the BSRIA Briefing 2024
Not just waiting for Net Zero, but driving it.
The ISO answer to what is a digital twin
Talking about digital twins in a more consistent manner.
Top tips and risks to look out for.
New Code of Practice for fire and escape door hardware
Published by GAI and DHF.
Retrofit of Buildings, a CIOB Technical Publication
Pertinent technical issues, retrofit measures and the roles involved.
New alliance will tackle skills shortage in greater Manchester
The pioneering Electrotechnical Training and Careers Alliance.
Comments
Really interesting research!