Procurement Route Pros & Cons - Revision history

Designing Buildings at 07:31, 18 November 2020

2020-11-18T07:31:25Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 07:31, 18 November 2020
Line 115:		Line 115:
	* SUSTAINABILITY		* SUSTAINABILITY

−	[[Category:Articles_needing_more_work]]	+	[[Category:Articles_needing_more_work]] [[Category:DCN_Commentary]]

Designing Buildings at 07:13, 14 April 2016

2016-04-14T07:13:45Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 07:13, 14 April 2016
Line 1:		Line 1:
−	Traditional Procurement	+	= Traditional Procurement =

	Good for:		Good for:
Line 10:		Line 10:
	* COMPLEX		* COMPLEX
	* COST – lump sum cost benefits unless multiple changes made		* COST – lump sum cost benefits unless multiple changes made
−
−

	Not Suited for:		Not Suited for:
Line 18:		Line 16:
	* COST – not a benefit if many changes made		* COST – not a benefit if many changes made
	* INCOMPLETE DRAWINGS – lead to delay, costs and claims of negligence		* INCOMPLETE DRAWINGS – lead to delay, costs and claims of negligence
−
−

	Contract: SBC11		Contract: SBC11
Line 33:		Line 29:
	* PREAGREED ALT DISPUTE RESOLUTION		* PREAGREED ALT DISPUTE RESOLUTION

−		+	= D&B Procurement =
−		+
−	D&B Procurement	+

	Good for:		Good for:
Line 46:		Line 40:
	* CLIENT RISK LOW		* CLIENT RISK LOW
	* NAMED SUB-CON – in employers requirements		* NAMED SUB-CON – in employers requirements
−
−

	Not suited for:		Not suited for:
Line 53:		Line 45:
	* QUALITY – cheapest route to meet contract spec can lead to low quality products/ build quality.		* QUALITY – cheapest route to meet contract spec can lead to low quality products/ build quality.
	* DESIGN FLEXIBILITY – request for change – costs/time implications		* DESIGN FLEXIBILITY – request for change – costs/time implications
−
−

	Contract: DB11		Contract: DB11
Line 66:		Line 56:
	* PRE AGREED DISPUTE RESOLUTION		* PRE AGREED DISPUTE RESOLUTION

−		+	= Management Contracting Procurement =
−		+
−	Management Contracting Procurement	+

	Good for:		Good for:
Line 77:		Line 65:
	* QUALITY – each package subcontracted to specialist		* QUALITY – each package subcontracted to specialist
	* DESIGN FLEXIBILITY – changes can be made throughout construction. Potential costs.		* DESIGN FLEXIBILITY – changes can be made throughout construction. Potential costs.
−
−

	Not suited for:		Not suited for:
Line 85:		Line 71:
	* FIXED COST - Prime cost basis per package. Fluctuations.		* FIXED COST - Prime cost basis per package. Fluctuations.
	* LACK OF AVAILABLE SPECIALISTS – would leave gaps in work to be undertaken.		* LACK OF AVAILABLE SPECIALISTS – would leave gaps in work to be undertaken.
−
−

	Contract: MC11		Contract: MC11
Line 96:		Line 80:
	* THIRD PARTY RIGHTS – funder-contractor		* THIRD PARTY RIGHTS – funder-contractor

−		+	= Construction Management Procurement =
−		+
−	Construction Management Procurement	+

	Good for:		Good for:
Line 111:		Line 93:
	* ALL BUILDING TYPES		* ALL BUILDING TYPES
	* EFFICIENCY – Early appointment of CM to aid programme		* EFFICIENCY – Early appointment of CM to aid programme
−
−

	Not suited for:		Not suited for:
Line 119:		Line 99:
	* FIXED COST- Prime cost basis per package.		* FIXED COST- Prime cost basis per package.
	* LACK OF AVAILABLE SPECIALISTS		* LACK OF AVAILABLE SPECIALISTS
−
−

	Contracts:		Contracts:

Archi1000: Created page with "Traditional Procurement Good for: * QUALITY – full design pre tender * DESIGN FLEXIBILITY – variations & instructions * SPECIALIST SUB-CON’S – Named specialist upda..."

2016-01-11T15:43:13Z

Created page with "Traditional Procurement Good for: * QUALITY – full design pre tender * DESIGN FLEXIBILITY – variations & instructions * SPECIALIST SUB-CON’S – Named specialist upda..."

New page

Traditional Procurement

Good for:

* QUALITY – full design pre tender
* DESIGN FLEXIBILITY – variations & instructions
* SPECIALIST SUB-CON’S – Named specialist update sbc11
* DESIGN CONTROL – through arch/CA
* CDPs – eg. M&E
* COMPLEX
* COST – lump sum cost benefits unless multiple changes made

Not Suited for:

* TIME – req full detailed pack pre tender
* COST – not a benefit if many changes made
* INCOMPLETE DRAWINGS – lead to delay, costs and claims of negligence

Contract: SBC11

* LUMP SUM PAYMENT
* CDM
* CDP’s
* NAMED SUB CONTRACTORS
* VARIATIONS/INSTRUCTIONS
* RETENTION
* COLLATERAL WARRANTIES
* TERMINATION PROVISIONS
* PREAGREED ALT DISPUTE RESOLUTION

D&B Procurement

Good for:

* TIME – Fast track, overlap design & construction
* COST – lump sum/ GMP
* SINGLE POINT RESPONSIBILITY – Contractor design and build responsibility
* COMPLEX
* NOVATION – can benefit quality. Prior knowledge, sub-con drawing review
* CLIENT RISK LOW
* NAMED SUB-CON – in employers requirements

Not suited for:

* QUALITY – cheapest route to meet contract spec can lead to low quality products/ build quality.
* DESIGN FLEXIBILITY – request for change – costs/time implications

Contract: DB11

* CONTRACTOR TO COMPLETE DESIGN +CARRY OUT WORKS
* LUMP SUM/GMP
* CDM
* COLLATERAL WARRANTIES
* TERMINATION PROVISIONS
* RETENTION
* PRE AGREED DISPUTE RESOLUTION

Management Contracting Procurement

Good for:

* COMPLEX/SPECIALIST – individually appointed packages to best suited sub-contractor
* POTENTIAL COST SAVING – Competitive tender
* TIME – Overlap design/construction
* QUALITY – each package subcontracted to specialist
* DESIGN FLEXIBILITY – changes can be made throughout construction. Potential costs.

Not suited for:

* INEXPERIENCED – risk high
* FIXED COST - Prime cost basis per package. Fluctuations.
* LACK OF AVAILABLE SPECIALISTS – would leave gaps in work to be undertaken.

Contract: MC11

* PRIME COST CONTRACT
* PROVISIONS FOR COLLATERAL WARRANTIES
* SUSTAINABILITY
* COLLABERATIVE WORKING
* THIRD PARTY RIGHTS – funder-contractor

Construction Management Procurement

Good for:

* COMPLEX/SPECIALIST - individually appointed packages to best suited sub-contractor
* TIME - Overlap design/construction

* DESIGN FLEXIBILITY - changes can be made throughout construction. Potential costs.

* POTENTIAL COST SAVING - Competitive tender
* QUALITY - each package subcontracted to specialist
* ALL BUILDING TYPES
* EFFICIENCY – Early appointment of CM to aid programme

Not suited for:

* UNEXPERIENCED EMPLOYER – risk high as appointing trade contractors
* FIXED COST- Prime cost basis per package.
* LACK OF AVAILABLE SPECIALISTS

Contracts:

CM/TC11

* EMPLOYER – TRADE CONTRACTOR
* LUMP SUM
* COLLATERAL WARRANTIES & THIRD PARTY RIGHTS
* RETENTION

CM/A

* EMPLYER – CM
* COLLATERAL WARRANTIES
* SUSTAINABILITY

[[Category:Articles_needing_more_work]]