Whessoe Oil and Gas & Cleveland Bridge UK Limited v Dale
Whessoe Oil and Gas & Cleveland Bridge UK Limited v Dale [2012] EWHC 1788 (TCC) - 29/06/12
The Defendant sought to strike out the First Claimant's Particulars of Claim and seek summary judgement against the First Claimant on the basis that they disclosed no reasonable grounds for bringing the claim or otherwise, as amounting to an abuse of the Court's process.
The Claimant issued proceedings against its managing director, who was the construction project manager on an unsuccessful project. The Claimant claimed that the Defendant had breached his statutory duties as a director and his contract in respect of management of the project. Following exchange of expert reports into project management, the Defendant argued the claim should be struck out because the expert's report was insufficient to support a case of breach of duty.
The Court considered Pantelli Associates v Corporate City Developments [2010 EWHC 3189 (TCC)]where it had been held that an expert's report was necessary to plead professional negligence. In this case the Court held that the expert report was not a necessary preliminary as the Defendant's obligations were as employee and director and differed from the question of an assumption of responsibility by an independent contractor considered in Pantelli, even though both involved the issue of reasonable skill and care.
The Judge therefore adjourned the Defendant's striking out application on terms that the Claimants must provide full particulars of the breaches of duty relied upon, of the losses claimed and of causation of such losses, such particulars to include all material facts upon which the Claimants rely.
[edit] External references
- Read the full decision.
- Pantelli Associates v Corporate City Developments [2010 EWHC 3189 (TCC).]
Featured articles and news
Not buildings. Happy holiday from DB.
Improving government projects with data and AI
Enabling better outcomes, efficient modern delivery and influential leadership on government projects.
BSRIA Living Laboratory Innovation Challenge
Final days for submission, closing March 29.
Windows, their frames, forms, factors and functions.
The hidden subtleties of U-Value calculations
Different contexts and what to include as variables.
A brief run down with related articles.
Electrical sector calls for safer public EV charge points
Serious concerns about electrical safety in the public domain.
Building Blocks manifesto presented to parliament
Architects Declare call in for support of five critical policies.
The four elements of project management with APM
Analysis, expectations, collaborative communication and partnerships.
City of London launches Heritage Building Retrofit Toolkit
Empowering owners to initiate necessary adaptations.
Guidance on RAAC in listed buildings
Published by Purcell, endorsed by IHBC, SPAB and C20.
Learning from the past.
Reluctance to hire people with criminal convictions revealed
Employing People with Criminal Convictions Report.
Tackling unconscious bias; Women's History Month
Personal reflections, as the last week of March approaches.